How much did clearing houses issue in Oct. and Nov. 1907 versus New York?
Research question: How much Clearing House loan certificate did each major city's clearing house issue in October and November 1907, and how did those volumes compare with the New York total?
The verified facts do not give city-by-city certificate volumes for October or November 1907. They show only that clearinghouses in other cities followed New York by issuing their own certificates and limiting cash payments 12. The New York Clearing House issued over $80 million in certificates during the panic 5, peaking at $88 million on December 16, 1907 10. The big six national banks accounted for more than half of New York's initial issues 7, and Hanover Bank took none 8. Because no figures for other cities appear in the facts, a comparison with the New York total cannot be made.
Sources
"Clearing house loan certificates were essentially “bridge loans” arranged between clearing house members. They enabled and were issued in anticipation of gold imports, which took a few weeks to arrive."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearing House Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2010)
"The large, New York City national banks acted as private liquidity providers by requesting (and the New York Clearing House issuing) a volume of clearing house loan certificates beyond their own immediate liquidity needs, in accord with their role as central reserve city banks in the national banking system."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearing House Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2010)
"They enabled and were issued in anticipation of gold imports, which took a few weeks to arrive."Liquidity Creation without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearing House Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2010)
"The large, New York City national banks acted as private liquidity providers by requesting (and the New York Clearing House issuing) a volume of clearing house loan certificates beyond their own immediate liquidity needs, in accord with their role as central reserve city banks in the national banking system."Liquidity Creation without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearing House Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2010)
"In terms of volume, the New York Clearing House issued over $80 million in clearing house loan certificates, which was substantial when compared to New York Clearing House"Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearinghouse Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2006)
"in 1907, the borrowers of clearing house loan certificates paid a 6 percent annual rate of interest to the holder of the certificate."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearinghouse Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2006)
"The big six national banks account for more than half of the initial issues of clearing house loan certificates."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearinghouse Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2006)
"One of the big six, Hanover Bank, took out no Clearing House loan certificates."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearinghouse Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2006)
"Muhleman (1908, pages 191-192) shows that New York Clearing House member banks had $267 million in reserves on October 19, 1907, and the level of reserves fell to $216 million on November 23, 1907."Liquidity Creation Without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearinghouse Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907 (2006)
"Outstanding NYCH CLCs peaked at $88 million on December 16 before gold imports from Europe expanded the supply of legal tender."United States: New York Clearing House Association,The Panic of 1907 (2022)
"By the time the NYCH canceled the last remaining CLCs in March, it had issued more than twice as many CLCs than in any previous crisis."United States: New York Clearing House Association,The Panic of 1907 (2022)
"Clearinghouses in other cities quickly followed suit by issuing CLCs and limiting cash payments."United States: New York Clearing House Association,The Panic of 1907 (2022)
"As an alternative means of relief Clearing House loan certificates will be issued. George F. Baker, pres president - ident president of the Clearing House, said no amount has been specified, but that the same method as that used In 1S03 will be followed."Image 1 of Santa Fe new Mexican (Santa Fe, N.M.), October 26, 1907
"Meanwhile the Clearing House loan certificates will be issued as a pre precautionary - cautionary precautionary , measure."Image 1 of Santa Fe new Mexican (Santa Fe, N.M.), October 26, 1907
Ask your own question