How and why did Israel start worshipping only Yahweh, dropping El and Asherah?
Research question: How did Yahweh come to be worshipped as the sole God of Israel, given that early texts and archaeological finds show him sharing worship with El, Asherah, and a divine council, and what does the evidence say about when and why this shift from henotheism to strict monotheism happened through the mona
The records show that early inscriptions pair Yahweh with other deities, as blessings from Kuntillet 'Ajrud are made 'by the name of Yahweh and his Asherah' 3, and the site names JHWH alongside El, Baal and Asherah 6. The Mesha Stele, dated to about 840 BCE, already treats JHWH as a national god of Israel 4, and before the exile Israel passed through phases of polylatry, with high places dedicated to several gods 11. Biblical texts show the shift being contested: Gideon's destruction of the Baal altar and Asherah provoked hostility from the local community 1315, and Deuteronomy placed the commandment of monolatry into a legendary Mosaic past to underline JHWH's exclusive claim to worship 10. The evidence does not settle when or why strict monotheism replaced this, since one scholar argues that travelers at Kuntillet 'Ajrud may have worshipped their own gods, so monotheistic worship cannot be assumed for the pre-exilic period 8, and monolatry differs from monotheism because it only forbids worshipping other gods rather than denying they exist 12. The newest fact in this set dates to 2024, about two years before October 2026 35.
Sources
"The inscriptions provide insights into conceptions of the Israelite pantheon, divine theophany, and theomachy in early Israelian religious ideology."Religion at Kuntillet ʿAjrud (2019)
"This article discusses whether 'srth in the phrase lyhwh ... wl'srth in inscriptions at Kuntillet 'Ajrud and Khirbet el-Qom refers to the goddess Asherah or her wooden symbol (here rendered "asherah").""Yahweh and His Asherah": the Goddess or Her Symbol? (1999)
"Znaleziono tam pochodzące z VIII w. p.n.e. inskrypcje"Religia starożytnych Izraelitów w czasach podzielonej monarchii w świetle inskrypcji z Kuntillet ‘Ajrud i tradycji żydowskiej (2024)
"Die Mescha-Stele (~840 v. Chr.) nennt JHWH als von Kemosch , dem Volksgott der Moabiter , besiegten Volksgott im Nordreich Israel , setzt dort also einen etablierten JHWH-Kult voraus."JHWH
"mogą stanowić dowód nie tylko na utrzymywanie się politeizmu wśród Izraelitów w okresie podzielonej monarchii"Religia starożytnych Izraelitów w czasach podzielonej monarchii w świetle inskrypcji z Kuntillet ‘Ajrud i tradycji żydowskiej (2024)
"Inschriften aus dem 8. Jahrhundert v. Chr. aus Kuntillet ʿAdschrud im nordwestlichen Sinai nennen JHWH neben den Göttern El , Ba’al und Aschera , die anscheinend zu JHWH gehörte."JHWH
"The fact that the inscriptions contain explicitly religious themes led some to conclude that the site had a cultic function."Religion at Kuntillet ʿAjrud (2019)
"Manfred Weippert vermutet, dass viele Reisende in Kuntillet ʿAdschrud Station machten und ihre jeweiligen Götter verehrten – so auch JHWH als Nationalgott Israels (bzw. Israels und Judas). Von einer monotheistischen JHWH-Verehrung lasse sich für die vorexilische Zeit also noch nicht sprechen."JHWH
"Ein außerisraelitischer JHWH-Kult ist unbelegt; dieser Name gehörte nicht zum traditionellen Pantheon der Region Kanaan ."JHWH
"Um den Alleinverehrungsanspruch JHWHs zu unterstreichen, wird im Deuteronomium das Gebot der Monolatrie in die legendäre Frühzeit verlegt und mit der Autorität des Mose verknüpft:"Monolatrie
"Im Alten Testament wird vielfach beschrieben, dass es im vorexilischen Israel (vor 597 v. Chr.) ausgeprägte Phasen der Polylatrie gab"Monolatrie
"bedeutet die Weiterentwicklung der Monolatrie zum Monotheismus die kategorische Bestreitung der Existenz anderer Götter."Monolatrie
"Take thy father’s bullock, and the second bullock of seven years old, and throw down the altar of Baal that thy father hath, and cut down the Asherah that is by it;"Judges 6:25-30 [Hebrew Bible (JPS 1917 English, Sefaria)]
"take the second bullock, and offer a burnt-offering with the wood of the Asherah which thou shalt cut down."Judges 6:25-30 [Hebrew Bible (JPS 1917 English, Sefaria)]
"Then the men of the city said unto Joash: ‘Bring out thy son, that he may die; because he hath broken down the altar of Baal, and because he hath cut down the Asherah that was by it.’"Judges 6:25-30 [Hebrew Bible (JPS 1917 English, Sefaria)]
"Will ye contend for Baal? or will ye save him? he that will contend for him, shall be put to death before morning; if he be a god, let him contend for himself, because one hath broken down his altar."Judges 6:25-30 [Hebrew Bible (JPS 1917 English, Sefaria)]
"Therefore on that day he was called Jerubbaal, saying: ‘Let Baal contend against him, because he hath broken down his altar.’"Judges 6:25-30 [Hebrew Bible (JPS 1917 English, Sefaria)]
"According to the psalmist, it is a feature of the only true God, which is the God of Israel, called upon to take power over the whole earth."Gods Doomed to Death. Psalm 82 as a Testimony of the Birth of Monotheism (2022)
"This could point to the fact that the Deuteronomists—at least with regard to this pericope—were working from a Vorlage in which Manasseh was rega"Asherah Goddess In Ugarit, Israel And The Old Testament ( Journal For The Study Of The Old Testament Supplement) (1997)
"Day notes that the sons of God (deriving from the Ugaritic bn 7) are clearly the sons of Yahweh in the OT, [and so] it follows that the sons of God were regarded as Asherah's offspring in syncretistic circles. Since the sons of God clearly correspond with the host of heaven (cf. Job 38:7). it appears that we may hold that the host of heaven were probably regarded as the offspring of Asherah' (1986"The Cult Of Asherah In Ancient Israel And Judah Evidence Hadley, Judith M University Of Cambridge Oriental Publications 57, Digital 9780521662352 Edbf 7389bc 8ed 078578a 6c 321fd 82824 Anna’s Archive
"Furthermore, the inscriptions from Khirbet el-Qom (chapter 4) and Kuntillet 'Ajrud (chapter 5) definitely mention asherah in connection with Yahweh."The Cult Of Asherah In Ancient Israel And Judah Evidence Hadley, Judith M University Of Cambridge Oriental Publications 57, Digital 9780521662352 Edbf 7389bc 8ed 078578a 6c 321fd 82824 Anna’s Archive
"Hóffken believes that the mention of Yahweh of Teman (and Yahweh of Samaria) here at 'Ajrud. together with the Hab. iii 3 passage, supports a ‘parcelling out’ ( Parzellierung) of Yahweh into a polyyahwistic context (1984, p. 89)."The Cult Of Asherah In Ancient Israel And Judah Evidence Hadley, Judith M University Of Cambridge Oriental Publications 57, Digital 9780521662352 Edbf 7389bc 8ed 078578a 6c 321fd 82824 Anna’s Archive
"Thompson, T. L., "The Intellectual Matrix of Early Biblical Narrative: Inclusive Monotheism in Persian Period Palestine", in D. V. Edelman (ed.), The Triumph of Elohim: From Yahwisms to Judaisms (CBET 13; Kampen: Pharos, 1995) 107-124."Monotheism in ancient Israel: recent discussion
"Stern, E., "From Many Gods to the One God: The Archaeological Evidence", in R. G. Kratz – H. Spieckermann (eds.), One God – One Cult – One Nation: Archaeological and Biblical Perspectives . In collaboration with B. Corzilius and T. Pilger (BZAW 405; Berlin: De Gruyter, 2010) 395-403."Monotheism in ancient Israel: recent discussion
"Smith, M. S., The Origins of Biblical Monotheism. Israel's Polytheistic Background and the Ugaritic Texts (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001)."Monotheism in ancient Israel: recent discussion
"und Moses", in J. Assmann – H. Strohm (eds.), Echnaton und Zarathustra. Zur Genese und Dynamik des Monotheismus (Lindauer Symposien für Religionsforschung, 3; München: Fink, 2012) 13-39."Monotheism in ancient Israel: recent discussion
"Stroumsa, G. G., The Idea of Semitic Monotheism: The Rise and Fall of a Scholarly Myth (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021)."Monotheism in ancient Israel: recent discussion
"This new view has emerged as a result of recent archaeological discoveries and a reassessment of the testimony of the biblical text."The Emergence of Monotheism in Ancient Israel: A Survey of Recent Scholarship - ScienceDirect
"Because the name of the god El appears as the divine element in the name of IsraEL, it has been supposed that El was the original god of Israel"El, Yahweh, and the Original God of Israel and the Exodus (2001)
"the Lord alone led them, there was no strange god with them."Deuteronomy 32:7-12 [Septuagint (Brenton English, 1844)]
"some evidence may point to El as the god associated with the Exodus from Egypt in some early biblical tradition."El, Yahweh, and the Original God of Israel and the Exodus (2001)
"When the Most High divided the nations, when he separated the sons of Adam, he set the bounds of the nations according to the number of the angels of God."Deuteronomy 32:7-12 [Septuagint (Brenton English, 1844)]
"They sacrificed to devils, and not to God; to gods whom they knew not: new and fresh [gods] came in, whom their fathers knew not."Deuteronomy 32:7-12 [Septuagint (Brenton English, 1844)]
"then he forsook the God that made him, and departed from God his Saviour."Deuteronomy 32:7-12 [Septuagint (Brenton English, 1844)]
"כִּ֗י אִם־בִּשְׁמֹנֶ֤ה עֶשְׂרֵה֙ שָׁנָ֔ה לַמֶּ֖לֶךְ יֹאשִׁיָּ֑הוּ נַעֲשָׂ֞ה הַפֶּ֧סַח הַזֶּ֛ה לַיהֹוָ֖ה בִּירוּשָׁלָֽ͏ִם׃"II Kings 23:13-18 [Hebrew Bible (Masoretic text, Sefaria)]
Ask your own question