Can only Ahura Mazda be worshiped in the Gathas, or just the top god?
Research question: Do the primary Gathic texts exclude other divine beings from worship, or do they only rank Ahura Mazda highest among them?
The records show that the Gathas present Ahura Mazda as the Highest Being and Creator, with Spenta-mainyu and Ako-mainyu absorbed into his higher Unity 2. The Gathas also treat the pre-Zoroastrian daevas not merely as demons but as false gods 10, and they do not show sacrifices to Mitra or Anahita, which appear in other texts 7. The records do not directly state whether the Gathas forbid worship of other divine beings, and the absence of named deities does not by itself prove monotheism 9. The evidence therefore leans toward ranking Ahura Mazda highest rather than a clear exclusion of other divine beings, though the Amesha Spentas are described as divinities and as objects of worship in later passages 1213.
Sources
"He is sometimes identified with Ahura Mazda, (Yasna XLTII, 2), sometimes he is distinguished from Him (Yasna XLV, 6; XLVII, 1) ; he must hence be a divine being who sometimes rises to the level of the Highest Godhead ; sometimes he is distinct from Him, and leads a separate existence."Zarathushtra in the Gathas, and in the Greek and Roman classics [electronic resource] (1897)
"The Highest Being, the Godhead, is plainly Ahura Mazda. ... Both Spenta-mainyu and Ako-mainyu are hence represented as tw^ins (JYasna XXX, 3); they do not exist alone for themselves, but each in relation to the other; both are absorbed in tiie higher Unity, Ahura Mazda."Zarathushtra in the Gathas, and in the Greek and Roman classics [electronic resource] (1897)
"If we further consider the fact that in the old Persian Cuneiform Inscriptions of the Achasmenian dynasty occurs the name of God, Auramazdd, as a single word which is only inflected at the end, it certainly follows hence that we have to deal here with the results of development in different historical epochs."Zarathushtra in the Gathas, and in the Greek and Roman classics [electronic resource] (1897)
"Him the place of my prophet give I’."The Gathas Of Zarathushtra (1900) (1900)
"not 'beings', but 'principles', 'things'"The Gâthas of Zarathushtra (Zoroaster) in metre and rhythm : being a second edition of the metrical versions in the author's edition of 1892-94 ... (1900)
"they meant not Ahura Mazda, but *Vouruna"A history of Zoroastrianism, page 378
"embora menores que Ahura Mazda, também recebem sacrifícios (Skjærvø, 2006, p. 2), elementos não observado no Antigo Avesta — os Gathas e o Yasna Haptanghaiti —"Zoroastrismo esculpido na fôrma monoteísta (2023)
"Did Mazdah alone of all the other divinities, have no opponent?"The hymns of Zoroaster, usually called the Gathas, page 422
"o que não justifica por si só uma evidência monoteísta, já que os Gathas são hinos a Ahura Mazda, ou seja, a menção a outras divindades, especialmente pelo nome, não é necessariamente esperada"Zoroastrismo esculpido na fôrma monoteísta (2023)
"Pela primeira vez, as antigas divindades indo-iranianas pré-zoroástricas eram tratadas não apenas como demônios, mas como falsas."Zoroastrismo esculpido na fôrma monoteísta (2023)
"The greatest of them, known to the Iranians as Ahura Mazda, ‘Lord"Textual sources for the study of Zoroastrianism, page 186
"à luz do Jovem Avesta essas afirmações não se confirmam, as Amesa Espenta são divindades."Zoroastrismo esculpido na fôrma monoteísta (2023)
"And we worship Vohu Manah (the Good Mind), and Asha Vahista (who is Righteousness the Best), and Khshathra-vairya, the Kingdom to be desired"Book, page 466
"He has six personified attributes (so one might state it), later, but not in the Gathas, described as Archangels, while in the Gathas they are at once the abstract attributes of God"Book, page 466
Ask your own question