ANTHILLAsk your own question
Answer · confidence: partial

What did chatbot users complain about in week one, and how did firms respond?

Research question: What did the first public chatbot users complain about in their first week, and how did companies respond?

The records show that Microsoft's Tay was shut down within 16 hours after posting offensive tweets 1. Microsoft blamed trolls who attacked the service, since the bot generated replies from its interactions with Twitter users 3, and it confirmed Tay was offline and apologized on its official blog 5. In the GPT-5 launch week of August 2025, Reddit users said the model broke their workflows 2, that the model picker routed queries to cheaper, less capable models 16, and one post calling it the 'biggest bait-and-switch in AI history' received 10,000 upvotes 17. OpenAI responded by letting Plus users keep using GPT-4o 7, doubling GPT-5 rate limits and blaming a broken autoswitcher for the 'dumber' behavior 10, and committing to show users which model handles each query 19. The sources do not establish that Tay or GPT-5 were the first public chatbots, and the later safety-routing complaints from September 2025 came weeks after launch rather than in the first week 412. The newest fact is from October 22, 2025, roughly a year before today, so the record may be out of date 24.

Checked 2026-10-22. Only documented and supported facts are used.
Dig deeper on this question

Sources

[1] supported
Tay was released as a Twitter bot, and within 16 hours it was shut down after posting inflammatory and offensive tweets.
"It caused controversy when the bot began to post inflammatory and offensive tweets through its Twitter account, causing Microsoft to shut down the service only 16 hours after its launch."
Tay (chatbot)
[2] supported
Users complained on Reddit that the GPT-5 launch was breaking their workflows and that many were disappointed after a day of using it.
"but because it seems to be breaking a lot of workflows, according to complaints posted to Reddit."
It Took Just 24 Hours of Complaints for OpenAI to Start Bringing Back Its Old Model
[3] supported
Microsoft attributed the offensive tweets to trolls who attacked the service, since the bot generated replies from its interactions with Twitter users.
"According to Microsoft, this was caused by trolls who "attacked" the service as the bot made replies based on its interactions with people on Twitter."
Tay (chatbot)
[4] supported
Paying ChatGPT users complained that their conversations were being rerouted away from their preferred model when topics became emotionally or legally sensitive, and there was no way to turn this off.
"There's currently no way to disable this behavior, and it's not particularly clear when the switches happen."
'We are not test subjects in your data lab': angry ChatGPT fans rebel against controversial new 'safety' feature as OpenAI defends move
[5] supported
Microsoft confirmed Tay was offline and apologized on its official blog for the offensive tweets.
"On March 25, Microsoft confirmed that Tay had been taken offline. Microsoft released an apology on its official blog for the controversial tweets posted by Tay."
Tay (chatbot)
[6] supported
ChatGPT's new safety guardrails sent users to a separate, more conservative AI model when the chatbot judged that it needed to be extra cautious.
"ChatGPT introduced new safety guardrails this month , which take users to a separate, more conservative AI model if the chatbot detects that it needs to be extra cautious in its responses."
'We are not test subjects in your data lab': angry ChatGPT fans rebel against controversial new 'safety' feature as OpenAI defends move
[7] supported
OpenAI responded by letting ChatGPT Plus users keep using GPT-4o, with Sam Altman saying usage would be watched before deciding how long legacy models would be offered.
"We will let Plus users choose to continue to use 4o. We will watch usage as we think about how long to offer legacy models for,"
It Took Just 24 Hours of Complaints for OpenAI to Start Bringing Back Its Old Model
[8] supported
After Italian regulators objected to its handling of user data, OpenAI added an age restriction limiting use of the app to people 18+ or 13+ with guardian permission.
"For a start, an age restriction was added, limiting the use of the app to people 18+ or 13+ with guardian permission."
8 Big Problems With OpenAI's ChatGPT
[9] supported
After Microsoft accidentally re-released Tay, its tweets appeared in the feeds of over 200,000 followers, annoying users, and the bot was taken offline again and its account made private.
"Because these tweets mentioned its own username in the process, they appeared in the feeds of 200,000+ Twitter followers, causing annoyance to users. The bot was quickly taken offline again, in addition to Tay's Twitter account being made private so new followers must be accepted before they can interact with Tay."
Tay (chatbot)
[10] supported
OpenAI said it would double GPT-5 rate limits for ChatGPT Plus users and blamed the model's perceived 'dumber' behavior on a broken autoswitcher.
"the company is going to double the GPT-5 rate limits for ChatGPT Plus users and blamed the fact that the new model seemed “dumber”"
It Took Just 24 Hours of Complaints for OpenAI to Start Bringing Back Its Old Model
[11] supported
OpenAI made its Privacy Policy more visible and offered an opt-out Google form so users could exclude their data from training ChatGPT and delete it entirely.
"It also made its Privacy Policy more visible and provided an opt-out Google form for users to exclude their data from training ChatGPT and delete it entirely if they want ."
8 Big Problems With OpenAI's ChatGPT
[12] supported
OpenAI executive Nick Turley responded publicly, explaining that the safety routing applies to sensitive and emotional topics and works on a per-message and temporary basis.
"Turley explains that the new safety routing system is for "sensitive and emotional topics", and works on a per-message and temporary basis."
'We are not test subjects in your data lab': angry ChatGPT fans rebel against controversial new 'safety' feature as OpenAI defends move
[13] supported
OpenAI's CEO said the company would change the user interface to make it easier to switch between different models.
"The CEO also said they’re going to change the UI to make it easier to switch between different models."
It Took Just 24 Hours of Complaints for OpenAI to Start Bringing Back Its Old Model
[14] supported
After GPT-5 launched, users on the r/ChatGPT subreddit quickly complained that the company was forcing everyone onto the new model, even those who preferred GPT-4o, o3, or other OpenAI models.
"The company was now forcing everyone to use GPT-5, even if they personally might have preferred GPT-4o, o3, or other OpenAI models."
Three big lessons from the GPT-5 backlash
[15] supported
Facebook's Galactica, an AI language model meant for academic research, was rapidly recalled after many people criticized it for producing wrong and biased scientific results.
"However, it was rapidly recalled after many people criticized it for outputting wrong and biased results related to scientific research."
8 Big Problems With OpenAI's ChatGPT
[16] supported
Some users said the new model picker routed their queries to cheaper, less capable models, which broke their professional workflows.
"For some users, the loss was primarily a professional one: a workflow broken, or a sense that the new, invisible model picker now routed all their queries to cheaper, less capable models than the ones they were used to."
Three big lessons from the GPT-5 backlash
[17] supported
One Reddit post calling OpenAI's change the 'biggest bait-and-switch in AI history' received 10,000 upvotes.
""OpenAI just pulled the biggest bait-and-switch in AI history and I'm done," read one Reddit post with 10,000 upvotes."
Three big lessons from the GPT-5 backlash
[18] supported
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman responded by saying the company would bring back GPT-4o and increase rate limits for the reasoning functionality in GPT-5.
"On Sunday, Altman said the company would bring back GPT-4o , and would increase rate limits for use of the "reasoning" functionality within GPT-5."
Three big lessons from the GPT-5 backlash
[19] supported
OpenAI also committed to showing users which model is being used when they submit a query.
"Altman also said the company would begin to display the model being used when a user makes a query."
Three big lessons from the GPT-5 backlash
[20] supported
After Italy temporarily blocked ChatGPT, OpenAI was prompted to improve the technology to meet consumer protection, data protection, privacy, and public security standards under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation.
"Italy’s action has prompted OpenAI to improve the ChatGPT technology to ensure that it meets the standards of consumer protection, data protection, privacy, and public security standards, as set out in the General Data Protection Regulation for European Union countries."
Should Indonesia Block ChatGPT? (2023)
[21] supported
At least seven people complained to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission that ChatGPT caused them severe delusions, paranoia, and emotional crises.
"At least seven people have complained to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission that ChatGPT caused them to experience severe delusions, paranoia, and emotional crises"
ChatGPT logo
[22] supported
The complaints were drawn from public records of FTC complaints mentioning ChatGPT, which date back to November 2022. The document does not describe a first-week complaint.
"citing public records of complaints mentioning ChatGPT since November 2022."
ChatGPT logo
[23] supported
OpenAI said it released a new GPT-5 default model to better detect and respond to signs of mental and emotional distress such as mania, delusion, and psychosis.
"In early October, we released a new GPT-5 default model in ChatGPT to more accurately detect and respond to potential signs of mental and emotional distress such as mania, delusion, psychosis, and de-escalate conversations in a supportive, grounding way"
ChatGPT logo
[24] supported
OpenAI said it expanded access to professional help and hotlines, re-routed sensitive conversations to safer models, added break reminders during long sessions, and introduced parental controls for teens.
"We’ve also expanded access to professional help and hotlines, re-routed sensitive conversations to safer models, added nudges to take breaks during long sessions, and introduced parental controls to better protect teens."
ChatGPT logo