Do crypto trading robots actually make money after fees and price slips?
Research question: What do academic papers find about whether automated or algorithmic crypto strategies earn returns after fees and slippage?
The records show that the evidence on whether automated crypto strategies earn returns after fees and slippage is thin and mixed 8. A 2022 neural-network study reports that its strategies beat buy-and-hold on Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Litecoin, but it does not say whether those returns were net of fees or slippage 7. A 2019 master's thesis reports a 27.8% net return in Euro terms, yet it also finds that not all individual strategies were profitable and that automated investing carries a high risk of loss 912. Work on Uniswap-style markets finds that slippage limits the arbitrage profit traders can actually obtain 5. The newest fact in this set is from 2022, roughly four years before October 2026, so the picture may be dated 11.
Sources
"Our optimal portfolio performs the best net of transaction cost"Dynamic Trading with Predictable Returns and Transaction Costs (2009)
"both strategies get the maximal and almost equal"Profit Maximization In Arbitrage Loops
"strategies and the MaxPrice strategy are not reliable"Profit Maximization In Arbitrage Loops
"The optimal strategy is not to trade all the way to the aim portfolio, since this entails too high transaction costs."Dynamic Trading with Predictable Returns and Transaction Costs (2009)
"slippage that limits the arbitrage profit that traders can get."Profit Maximization In Arbitrage Loops
"Arbitrageurs’ ability to do so is limited, however, by transaction costs, and our model provides a tractable and flexible framework for the study of the dynamic implications of this limitation."Dynamic Trading with Predictable Returns and Transaction Costs (2009)
"We show that the proposed trading algorithms are better when compared to the traditional buy and hold strategy in terms of both stability and returns."Stochastic Neural Networks-Based Algorithmic Trading for the Cryptocurrency Market (2022)
"Evidence is thinner for durable net performance."Artificial Intelligence in Equity and Crypto Markets:
"The results show that algorithmic cryptocurrency trading can be profitable, as the developed trading system achieves a net return of 27.8% in Euro terms."Algorithmic Cryptocurrency Trading (2019)
"These findings support the existence of structured signals and frictions; they do not imply riskless machine-extractable profit."Artificial Intelligence in Equity and Crypto Markets:
"Some experiments showed that the use of specific technical trading rules allows generating excess returns, which is useful to cryptocurrency traders and investors in making optimal trading and investment deci-"Cryptocurrency trading: a comprehensive survey (2022)
"However, not all strategies win, which shows that an automated investment approach also entails a high risk of loss."Algorithmic Cryptocurrency Trading (2019)
"Cong et al. (2023) find extensive wash trading across less regulated exchanges, and Aloosh and Li (2024) provide direct evidence of wash trading in Bitcoin markets."Artificial Intelligence in Equity and Crypto Markets:
"Beats selected learned baselines; does not establish superiority to all traditional signals"Artificial Intelligence in Equity and Crypto Markets:
Ask your own question