Which ideas to limit the president's firing power happened or went to court?
Research question: Which of the plan's proposals to limit presidential removal power over independent agency officials have been carried out or ruled on by courts?
The facts do not list the plan's full set of removal-power proposals, but Project 2025's Justice Department chapter urged the next administration to argue that Humphrey's Executor violates the separation of powers, and the administration made that argument in the Wilcox case and then in Trump v. Slaughter 14. In Trump v. Slaughter, decided June 29, 2026, the Supreme Court overruled Humphrey's Executor by a 6–3 vote and held that for-cause removal protections for agency heads exercising executive power violate the separation of powers 911. The Court spared the Federal Reserve from that ruling, and in the companion case Trump v. Cook it refused by a 5–4 vote to let the president remove Lisa Cook while the case returns to lower courts 121516. Other removal challenges show no merits ruling in these records: Dellinger v. Bessent was closed after the petitioner withdrew it 1, Harris v. Bessent was consolidated with Trump v. Wilcox at the Supreme Court 3, and Aviel v. Gor was appealed to the D.C. Circuit 4. The newest fact is dated June 29, 2026, roughly three months before October 2026 9.
Sources
"Dellinger v. Bessent (D.D.C.), 1:25-cv-00385, [ 368 ] appealed to the D.C. Cir., 25-5025 [ 369 ] / 25-5028 [ 370 ] / 25-5052, [ 371 ] appealed to the Supreme Court, Bessent v. Dellinger , 24A790 [ 372 ] (case closed after petitioner withdrew it)"Legal affairs of the second Trump presidency
"In Seila Law LLC v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2020), the Roberts Court held 5–4 that the Executive Vesting Clause gives "the entire 'executive Power' ... to the President alone.""Authoritarianism during the Trump presidencies
"Harris v. Bessent (D.D.C.), 1:25-cv-00412, [ 375 ] appealed to the D.C. Cir., 25-5055 [ 376 ] and 25-5037, [ 377 ] appealed to the Supreme Court, Bessent v. Harris (consolidated with Trump v. Wilcox )"Legal affairs of the second Trump presidency
"Aviel v. Gor (D.D.C.), 1:25-cv-00778, [ 364 ] appealed to the D.C. Cir., 25-5105 [ 365 ]"Legal affairs of the second Trump presidency
"The Court reaffirmed that precedents found in Humphrey's Executor and Morrison were the only exceptions to this removal power."Authoritarianism during the Trump presidencies
"He undertook mass firings of employees , inspectors general , and independent agency and oversight board members who might obstruct him."Authoritarianism during the Trump presidencies
"Legal analysts said these actions set up Supreme Court tests on agencies Congress insulated from presidential control."Authoritarianism during the Trump presidencies
"In Trump v. Slaughter , the U.S. Supreme Court overruled Humphrey's Executor v. United States (1935), holding that Congress generally cannot shield leaders of executive agencies from presidential removal through "for-cause" protections."Supreme Court’s Trump v. Slaughter Decision Reshapes the Administrative State
"In Trump v. Slaughte r, a 6–3 majority overruled Humphrey’s Executor v. United States"The End of the Independent Agency: Supreme Court Overrules Humphrey's Executor
"On Monday morning, the Supreme Court overruled Humphrey’s Executor , the 1935 decision that for more than 90 years let Congress shield the heads of independent agencies from being fired at a president’s whim. The vote was 6–3."Trump Just Got the Supreme Court to Do Project 2025 for Him
"Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the Court, held that for-cause removal protections for the heads of agencies exercising executive power violate the Constitution’s separation of powers."The End of the Independent Agency: Supreme Court Overrules Humphrey's Executor
"By 5–4, with the chief justice and Justice Brett Kavanaugh joining the three liberal justices who had just dissented in the FTC case, the court refused to let the president remove Cook from the Federal Reserve."Trump Just Got the Supreme Court to Do Project 2025 for Him
"The district court, applying Humphrey’s Executor , ordered her restoration. The Supreme Court stayed that order, granted certiorari before judgment, and reversed."The End of the Independent Agency: Supreme Court Overrules Humphrey's Executor
"Within months, the administration made that argument, in Wilcox, then in Trump v. Slaughter , the Federal Trade Commission case the court has now decided."Trump Just Got the Supreme Court to Do Project 2025 for Him
"today’s companion case, Trump v. Cook , appears to recognize an exception — “a special arrangement sanctioned by history” — for central banking that serves to insulate the Federal Reserve Board of Governors from presidential removal."The End of the Independent Agency: Supreme Court Overrules Humphrey's Executor
"In a companion case handed down the same hour, the court spared the Federal Reserve, the one exception it had long flagged, and let board member Lisa Cook keep her seat by a 5–4 vote."Trump Just Got the Supreme Court to Do Project 2025 for Him
Ask your own question