Were bitcoin's first 2009 trades just people sending coins, or real swaps?
Research question: What were the first bitcoin transactions after the network launched in January 2009, and were they transfers between people or real exchanges of value?
The first peer-to-peer transaction was sending bitcoin from one public address to another, at block 170 on 12 January 2009 1. It was a transfer of 10 bitcoins from Satoshi Nakamoto to Hal Finney, described as a transfer between two people rather than an exchange for goods or money 23. Before that, the early blocks held only coinbase transactions that created 50 BTC as miner rewards 4. The transfer was probably a test of whether the software and ledger worked, not an exchange of goods or services 78. Because bitcoin had no market value then, the 10 BTC carried no real value, so the transfer was not an exchange of real value 418.
Sources
"The first P2P transaction by which BTC was sent from one public address to another occurred at block 170 , on 12 January 2009, or seven days before block 1,018, and one day after Finney installed his Bitcoin client."Bitcoin: the signature of block 1,018 is Hal Finney's
"received 10 bitcoins from Nakamoto in the world's first bitcoin transaction on 12 January 2009 (block 170)."History of bitcoin
"Bitcoin's creator, known only by the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto, transferred 10 bitcoins to Hal Finney, an American software developer."First Bitcoin transaction
"In fact, it should be mentioned that the first blocks were mined by Satoshi and Hal Finney without any transactions other than coinbase transactions with which 50 BTC were created as a reward for the miners. After all, at that time BTC had no market, so its value was zero."Bitcoin: the signature of block 1,018 is Hal Finney's
"One of the first miners included James Howells , who subsequently lost thousands of Bitcoin to a landfill in Newport ."History of bitcoin
"The first transaction was 10 $BTC sent on Jan. 12, 2009, and it was confirmed at block height 170."Recently Signed 2009 Bitcoin Block Reward Linked to Hal Finney's Set of BTC Transactions
"The transaction was a test to see if the client worked, and that the "blockchain" distributed ledger updated correctly."First Bitcoin transaction
"That transaction is famous, and it is known that it was 10 BTC sent probably for testing by Satoshi Nakamoto to Hal Finney."Bitcoin: the signature of block 1,018 is Hal Finney's
"This historic moment at block 170 saw Satoshi transfer 10 BTC to computer scientist Hal Finney, making him the recipient of the Bitcoin first transaction."Satoshi's First Move: 16 Years of Bitcoin's Legacy - U.Today
"Block 1,018 and the bitcoin address 1NChf are both linked to the first $BTC transaction that saw 10 $BTC sent from Satoshi Nakamoto to Hal Finney and a great deal of $BTC blocks associated with Finney."Recently Signed 2009 Bitcoin Block Reward Linked to Hal Finney's Set of BTC Transactions
"It is not known whether Finney knew Nakamoto, but it is known that he in fact worked with him on that first Bitcoin software, helping Nakamoto test and fine-tune it."Bitcoin: the signature of block 1,018 is Hal Finney's
"Satoshi Nakamoto , Bitcoin's pseudonymous creator(s), performed the first peer-to-peer (P2P) transaction on the Bitcoin network."Satoshi's First Move: 16 Years of Bitcoin's Legacy - U.Today
"On January 12, 2009, just a few days after the initial public software release, Satoshi Nakamoto sent 10 bitcoins to Hal Finney in a landmark test to prove the network worked."The Bitcoin transaction that changed everything—17 years ...
"While parsing the first 1,025 mined $BTC blocks, the data shows that nearly every block Nakamoto mined is unspent, except for the block 9 transactions."Recently Signed 2009 Bitcoin Block Reward Linked to Hal Finney's Set of BTC Transactions
"After all, the last outgoing transaction made from the address that received the 10 BTC from Satoshi in block 170 is dated 6 September 2017, so well after Finney's death."Bitcoin: the signature of block 1,018 is Hal Finney's
"As was common in the early days, the transaction cost 0 BTC."Satoshi's First Move: 16 Years of Bitcoin's Legacy - U.Today
"His 10-coin transaction with Satoshi came at Block #170, meaning Finney likely already had quite a stash by that time (at least, by today’s standards)."The Bitcoin transaction that changed everything—17 years ...
"Finney received 10 BTC from Satoshi , which would have been worth zero dollars in 2009."Satoshi's First Move: 16 Years of Bitcoin's Legacy - U.Today
"Hal Finney was the first person, other than Satoshi, to express enthusiasm for Bitcoin, and possibly the first individual, other than Satoshi, to start a mining node on the brand-new Bitcoin network."The Bitcoin transaction that changed everything—17 years ...
"Similar to subsequent Bitcoin blocks, it rewarded 50 BTC, but this can never be spent."Satoshi's First Move: 16 Years of Bitcoin's Legacy - U.Today
"According to the man himself, he began mining “around Block 70-something”."The Bitcoin transaction that changed everything—17 years ...
Ask your own question