ANTHILLAsk your own question
Answer · confidence: partial

Which old digital money let people pay each other, not as a sale?

Research question: Which pre-bitcoin digital money service let users pay each other in units without any cash changing hands, and how would a reader tell that apart from a sale?

The facts describe electronic money as a non-personalized payment product that can circulate separately from the banking system 1. The records show that Yandex.Money began operating on 24 July 2002 as a joint project of Yandex and PayCash 2, with PayCash supplying the technology platform 3. The facts do not state that Yandex.Money let users pay each other in units, so that match is an inference rather than a verified finding. The records show that an electronic money payment requires only the recipient's details, whereas non-cash transfers are always personalized and both parties' details are known 4. The facts do not describe how a sale works, so they only partly answer how a reader would tell a unit transfer from a sale.

Checked 2026-10-21. Only documented and supported facts are used.
Dig deeper on this question

Sources

[1] supported
Electronic money is described as a non-personalized payment product that can circulate separately from the banking circulation of money.
"Электронные деньги, являясь неперсонифицированным платёжным продуктом, могут иметь отдельное обращение, отличное от банковского обращения денег"
Электронные деньги
[2] supported
The electronic payment service 'Yandex.Money' started operating on 24 July 2002 as a joint project of Yandex and the St. Petersburg company PayCash.
"Сервис электронных платежей «Яндекс. Деньги» начал работу 24 июля 2002 года как совместный проект «Яндекса» и петербургской компании PayCash"
ЮMoney
[3] supported
In the partnership, PayCash supplied the technology platform while Yandex supplied tools for working with a mass audience.
"В этом партнёрстве PayCash предоставил технологическую платформу, а «Яндекс» — инструменты для работы с массовой аудиторией"
ЮMoney
[4] supported
Electronic money is best compared to cash because non-cash money transfers are always personalized and both parties' details are known, whereas an electronic money payment only requires knowing the recipient's details.
"Электронные деньги корректнее всего сравнивать с наличными деньгами, так как обращение безналичных денег обязательно персонифицировано, и известны реквизиты обеих сторон. В случае расчётов электронными деньгами достаточно знать реквизиты получателя денег."
Электронные деньги