ANTHILLAsk your own question
Answer · confidence: partial

What online money came before bitcoin, and did any work like crypto trades?

Research question: What were the digital currencies and online payment systems that existed before bitcoin, and did any of them involve trades that look like today's crypto trades?

The records show several digital currency and payment systems that operated before or alongside bitcoin, including DigiCash's eCash, which was launched as CyberBucks 1215, and WebMoney, E-gold, and Liberty Reserve 426. Some of their activity resembles today's crypto trading: WebMoney's INDX platform first handled derivatives tied to company shares and later introduced notes backed by popular cryptocurrencies 1, and Liberty Reserve was described as the leading payment channel for traders in emerging and frontier markets 31. The newest fact about how these systems were traded is from 2018, when bitcoin was traded alongside older e-money systems on BestChange 9, so the evidence does not describe the current market as of October 2026. The evidence only partly answers the question: it confirms the systems and some trading parallels, but gives no details on how the crypto-backed notes worked or when they were introduced.

Checked 2026-10-22. Only documented and supported facts are used.
Dig deeper on this question

Sources

[1] supported
WebMoney's INDX trading platform, launched in 2005, first handled traditional derivatives tied to shares of large global and Russian companies, and later introduced notes backed by popular cryptocurrencies.
"В 2005 году появилась торговая площадка INDX. Изначально она предназначалась для торгов традиционными деривативами , базовым активом которых являются акции крупных мировых и российских компаний. Но постепенно были введены в оборот новые ноты, обеспеченные популярными криптовалютами"
WebMoney
[2] supported
The document cites Sergei Mavrodi's MMM Global as an example of an organized financial pyramid scheme, though it does not say how it worked or when it existed.
"примером может служить организованная Сергеем Мавроди «MMM Global»"
Биткоин
[3] supported
A digital currency exchanger is a web service that lets clients exchange digital currencies such as Bitcoin for other assets, including national currencies and other digital currencies.
"оказывает клиентам услуги по обмену цифровых валют (например, Bitcoin ) на другие активы, включая национальные валюты и другие цифровые валюты"
Онлайн-сервис обмена цифровых валют
[4] supported
When BestChange launched in June 2007, the most popular exchange directions were WebMoney and E-gold, two electronic money systems.
"Популярными направлениями на тот момент были WebMoney и E-gold ."
BestChange
[5] supported
On 20 July 2007 WebMoney introduced WMG wallets, whose funds were backed by gold bullion of at least 995 fineness (99.5% purity).
"20 июля 2007 года в системе WebMoney были введены кошельки принципиально нового для России типа — WMG или WebMoney Gold. Средства в кошельках системы такого типа обеспечены слиточным золотом не ниже 995-й пробы (то есть 99,5 % чистоты)"
WebMoney
[6] supported
BestChange began monitoring on 19 June 2007, when its listing included 25 exchangers.
"Мониторинг начал работать 19 июня 2007 года. На момент запуска в листинге было 25 обменников."
BestChange
[7] supported
BestChange is a Russian aggregator website that compares exchange offices and exchange rates for electronic money.
"российский сайт-агрегатор данных об обменных пунктах и курсах обмена электронных денег."
BestChange
[8] supported
E-gold, an early digital currency service, ceased operations in 2009, after three of its senior executives pleaded guilty in July 2008 to money laundering conspiracy and running an unlicensed money transmitting business.
"Компания E-Gold прекратила свою деятельность в 2009 году."
Онлайн-сервис обмена цифровых валют
[9] supported
In 2018 the popular exchange directions on the site were Qiwi, Bitcoin, Yandex.Money and Perfect Money, showing bitcoin was traded alongside older e-money systems.
"В 2018 году ими являются Qiwi , Bitcoin [ 1 ] [ 2 ] , Яндекс.Деньги [ 3 ] и Perfect Money [ 4 ] [ 5 ] ."
BestChange
[10] supported
Liberty Reserve, a digital currency exchange, was shut down in May 2013 after its alleged founder and four co-founders were arrested, and authorities said it was likely the largest money laundering case ever charged.
"В мае 2013 года организация, осуществлявшая онлайн-обмен цифровых валют — Liberty Reserve — была закрыта"
Онлайн-сервис обмена цифровых валют
[11] supported
The site's 'Double exchange' feature finds a route of two exchanges through a transit currency, so users can trade between currencies that have no direct exchange.
"Функция «Двойной обмен» подбирает схему из двух обменов через транзитную валюту"
BestChange
[12] supported
David Chaum founded DigiCash Inc. in 1989 to create a digital currency for secure and anonymous internet transactions.
"In 1989, David Chaum , an American cryptographer and researcher, founded DigiCash Inc. , a company aimed at creating a digital currency that could ensure secure and anonymous transactions on the Internet, akin to cash in the digital world."
May 27, 1994: the first electronic payment with eCash - Atlas21
[13] supported
eCash was the first electronic payment system to use asymmetric cryptography and 'blind signatures' to allow banks to verify transactions without knowing the sender's identity.
"eCash, in particular, was the first electronic payment system based on asymmetric cryptography that utilized “ blind signatures ,” a technique that allows a document to be signed without knowing its content. This ensured that banks could verify the validity of transactions without knowing the sender’s identity."
May 27, 1994: the first electronic payment with eCash - Atlas21
[14] supported
DigiCash declared bankruptcy in 1998 and sold its assets to eCash Technologies due to a lack of user base and bank skepticism.
"All these factors led DigiCash to declare bankruptcy in 1998 and subsequently sell its assets to eCash Technologies."
May 27, 1994: the first electronic payment with eCash - Atlas21
[15] supported
eCash was launched as its own distinct currency called CyberBucks, which was also issued by banks in national currencies.
"eCash was launched online as its own CyberBucks currency and also issued under license by banks around the world in national currencies."
ECASH - chaum.com
[16] supported
DigiCash partnered with Deutsche Bank in 1996 to test eCash in Germany, with a pilot involving 1,500 clients.
"DigiCash Partners with Deutsche Bank to Test eCash in Germany DigiCash’s eCash™ to be Issued by Deutsche Bank DigiCash - 03/26/1996 Shopping with Secure Payments on the Internet - Deutsche Bank Starts eCash Pilot with 1500 Clients DigiCash - 08/04/1997"
ECASH - chaum.com
[17] supported
Hashcash, a proof-of-work system proposed in 1997 by Adam Back, was designed to limit email spam and denial-of-service attacks rather than function as a digital currency.
"Hashcash is a proof-of-work system used to limit email spam and denial-of-service attacks . Hashcash was proposed in 1997 by Adam Back [ 1 ] and described more formally in Back's 2002 paper "Hashcash – A Denial of Service Counter-Measure"."
Hashcash - Wikipedia
[18] supported
The concept of requiring users to compute a moderately hard function to prevent junk mail was proposed by Cynthia Dwork and Moni Naor in 1992, predating Hashcash.
"The idea "...to require a user to compute a moderately hard, but not intractable function..." was proposed by Cynthia Dwork and Moni Naor in their 1992 paper "Pricing via Processing or Combatting Junk Mail"."
Hashcash - Wikipedia
[19] supported
Bitcoin mining utilizes a similar hash-based proof-of-work mechanism to Hashcash, where miners must discover a nonce by brute force to create an acceptable block hash.
"In contrast to hashcash in mail applications that relies on recipients to set manually an amount of work intended to deter malicious senders, the Bitcoin cryptocurrency network employs a different hash-based proof-of-work challenge to enable competitive Bitcoin mining . A Bitcoin miner runs a computer program that collects unconfirmed transactions from users on the network. Together, these can for"
Hashcash - Wikipedia
[20] supported
Microsoft implemented a deprecated open specification called "Email Postmark" that was similar to Hashcash and used in their Exchange, Outlook, and Hotmail infrastructure.
"Microsoft also designed and implemented a now deprecated [ 12 ] open specification called "Email Postmark". It is similar to Hashcash. [ 13 ] This was part of Microsoft's Coordinated Spam Reduction Initiative (CSRI). [ 14 ] The Microsoft email postmark variant of Hashcash is implemented in the Microsoft mail infrastructure components Exchange, Outlook, and Hotmail."
Hashcash - Wikipedia
[21] supported
The Penny Post software project implemented Hashcash in the Mozilla Thunderbird email client, naming the project after the historical one-penny mailing service.
"The Penny Post software project [ 10 ] on SourceForge implements Hashcash in the Mozilla Thunderbird email client . [ 11 ] The project is named for the historical availability of conventional mailing services that cost the sender just one penny, known as penny posts ."
Hashcash - Wikipedia
[22] documented
Hashcash was proposed in May 1997 as a mechanism to throttle abuse of internet resources like email and anonymous remailers.
"Hashcash[1] was originally proposedas a mechanism tothrottlesystematic abuseofun-meteredinternetresources such as email, and anonymous remailers in May 1997."
PDF Hashcash -A Denial of Service Counter-Measure
[23] supported
Hashcash was discussed as a minting mechanism for Wei Dai's b-money electronic cash proposal, which is described as an electronic cash scheme without a banking interface.
"hashcashasamintingmechanismforWeiDai’sb-moneyelectroniccashproposal,anelectroniccashscheme withoutabankinginterface[19]"
PDF Hashcash -A Denial of Service Counter-Measure
[24] supported
Hal Finney and Thomas Boschloo independently suggested an improvement to hashcash in March 2002 to find a collision against a fixed output string to reduce verification costs.
"Asubsequent improvementsuggestedindependentlybyHalFinney[6]andThomasBoschloo[7]forhashcashistofindacollision againstafixedoutputstring."
PDF Hashcash -A Denial of Service Counter-Measure
[25] supported
Hashcash was originally proposed in May 1997 as a mechanism to throttle systematic abuse of un-metered internet resources like email and anonymous remailers.
"Hashcash was originally proposed as a mechanism to throttle systematic abuse of un-metered internet resources such as email, and anonymous remailers in May 1997 ."
Hashcash - A Denial of Service Counter-Measure
[26] supported
Liberty Reserve was a centralized digital currency service based in Costa Rica.
"Liberty Reserve was a Costa Rica -based centralized digital currency service that billed itself as the "oldest, safest and most popular payment processor , serving millions all around a world"."
Liberty Reserve
[27] supported
In 1932, the Hawarden City Council in Iowa issued 300 paper trade coupons worth $1 each to pay workers on a paving project, a non-digital local scrip currency that had to be stamped at each transaction and was redeemed by the city.
"The Hawarden City Council started with an * Issue of 300 trade coupons, worth $1 each, to pay workers on a paving project."
Image 24 of Evening star (Washington, D.C.), December 9, 1932
[28] supported
Before Liberty Reserve, Arthur Budovsky and Vladimir Kats ran a digital currency exchange called Gold Age from 2002 to 2006.
"From 2002 to 2006, United States businessmen Arthur Budovsky and Vladimir Kats ran a digital currency exchange service known as Gold Age ."
Liberty Reserve
[29] supported
Liberty Reserve's digital currencies were tied to the U.S. dollar, the euro, or ounces of gold, and deposited money was converted into them.
"Deposited funds were then "converted" into Liberty Reserve Dollars or Liberty Reserve Euros, which were tied to the value of the U.S. dollar and the euro , respectively, or to ounces of gold."
Liberty Reserve
[30] supported
Liberty Reserve earned revenue by charging about a 1% fee on each transfer, and transactions were irrevocable with no limits on size.
"The service made money by charging a small fee, about 1%, on each transfer. [ 1 ] Transactions were "100% irrevocable"."
Liberty Reserve
[31] supported
Liberty Reserve was popular with currency brokers and was described as the leading payment channel for traders in emerging and frontier markets, a trading-style use similar to today's crypto exchanges.
"Service was popular among currency brokers and multilevel marketing companies. [ 5 ] According to Forex Magnates, a specialized forex news service, Liberty Reserve was "the leading payment channel for traders in emerging and frontier markets.""
Liberty Reserve