ANTHILLAsk your own question
Nature and Space · 6 min read · full version

Can a Message Come Back From the Past? What the Checked Record Shows

General relativity permits closed timelike curves 44, which is the starting point for treating a message sent backward in time as physically possible.

Watch the 2-minute video
Standard Oil of Ohio (SOHIO) Public domain
Last checked 2026-10-23. Sentence check: 6 paragraphs passed, 11 repaired, 4 removed. Every number links to the exact quote. Read the easy version

In short

People have sealed records for the future for centuries, such as a box found in Aschersleben in 1862 that held documents dating back to 1599 15, and Oglethorpe University's Crypt of Civilization, sealed in 1940 and not to be opened until the year 8113 17. Physics allows the idea of a loop that lets a particle return to its own past, called a closed timelike curve 41, and Stephen Hawking proposed chronology protection because such loops can appear in general relativity 7. Wormholes could also create these loops 57, but their stability depends heavily on exotic matter, which has not been observed 52. Digital records face their own problem, since a 1999 report found no viable long-term strategy yet existed to keep digital information readable 64, so emulation of old systems was proposed 63. In 2026, opened capsules showed how much damage time can do: Mountain View's 1976 bicentennial capsule was damaged by water and mold and its unveiling was scrapped 21, and the 1952 copper box was found corroded and dented 35. Today, archivists use checksums to catch silent corruption, called bit rot 68, and keep multiple copies in different locations and on different media 69.

Sealed boxes from 1599 to 1952

The oldest time capsule the document mentions was found in 1862 in the Johannisturm in Aschersleben 15. It was a sheet-metal box holding six documents, the oldest dated 1599 15. Separately, one of the Aschersleben documents, dated 12 July 1652, described the suffering caused by the Thirty Years' War in Aschersleben, and other writings reported the outbreak of the plague 16.

In 1940, Oglethorpe University sealed its Crypt of Civilization in a disused swimming pool. The Crypt is not to be opened until the year 8113 17.

In 1952, a copper box was placed at a hospital expansion cornerstone ceremony. It contained blueprints, a Bible, historical pictures, photographs, and legal and historical documents 37.

Can physics allow a message to go back?

The idea that light-speed limits might be broken goes back at least to the 1960s, when physicist Gerald Feinberg worked out a formal place for faster-than-light particles in theory, using 'imaginary mass' 70. If a tachyon could outrun light, different observers could disagree about the order of events, so one frame could see a particle absorbed before it was emitted 71. That reversal of event order revived the old fear that such particles would destroy causality 72.

A closed timelike curve is a worldline that loops back so a particle can return to and interact with its own past 41. Kurt Gödel's universe was dismissed as a model of physical reality because it is unlike the universe we live in 10. The Novikov self-consistency principle says only globally consistent solutions can occur in such spacetimes, which is what keeps loops from producing contradictions 56. In 1992, Gott spacetime was shown to contain closed timelike curves without a locally anomalous stress-energy 74.

Wormholes add another route. Generic relative motion of their two mouths, or gravitational redshift at the mouths, can in principle produce closed timelike curves 57, so traversing a wormhole could carry a traveler into the past or future. However, wormhole stability depends heavily on negative energy densities, and exotic matter has not been observed 52. Stephen Hawking formulated the chronology protection conjecture because some solutions of the equations of general relativity contain closed timelike curves 7. In 2005, Heinrich Päs, Thomas Weiler and Sandip Pakvasa discussed the possibility that sterile neutrinos could take shortcuts through extra dimensions 11. New Scientist covered the idea in a 2006 article titled 'At last a way to test time travel' 9. In 2009, Heinrich Päs, Sandip Pakvasa, Thomas Weiler and James Dent showed that certain warped extra-dimensional spacetime scenarios could in principle allow closed timelike curves 8.

Archives built to last (1999–2009)

A 1999 report on digital preservation found that no viable long-term strategy yet existed to ensure digital information would remain readable in the future 64. Its central proposal was emulation: running obsolete systems on future, unknown systems so a document's original software can still run 63.

A reviewer describes a book as examining the problem of storing, reading and using digital documents for periods longer than 50 years 1. Preserving and using data over the long term involves complicated research challenges and organizational efforts 4. Open standards such as PDF/A are considered relatively long-lived 2, and the PDF/A-1b level requires that all images and fonts used be contained within the PDF file itself, with references to resources outside the file forbidden 6.

By 2009, emulation was proposed as a complement to migration, the otherwise dominant strategy, and was said to have convincing advantages for dynamic digital objects 67. Preserving an object under the view path model meant extending its metadata and storing secondary objects so its original environment could be reproduced 65.

Lab tests and quantum loops (2008–2016)

One quantum-information document claims that a party with access to closed timelike curves could transmit an arbitrarily large amount of classical information using a quantum system of fixed size 76. Reference 73 says that the causal self-consistency condition for closed timelike curves can produce nonlinear interactions on qubits that respect chronology, which is the kind of backward-in-time physics that a backward message would raise. It does not discuss sealed boxes opened on a future date 73.

In 2011, Bennett and Schumacher's postselected quantum teleportation became the basis for a model of closed timelike curves that gives physically different results from Deutsch's model 42. Under the postselected model, the future existence of a P-CTC can affect the present outcome of an experiment 45. Sending a qubit into the past through such a loop is framed as analogous to teleporting the qubit's state 39.

Information encoded in a quantum field can remain accessible to a receiver who switches on their detector at a later time, after the light-speed signal has already passed 75.

Spring and summer 2026: headlines and failed capsules

On May 9, 2026, physicists said closed timelike curves could in principle let information return to an earlier point in time 53. They also noted that in some quantum experiments with entangled photons, the photons appeared to exchange information retroactively, but no person or object travelled through time 55.

When the capsule's lid was removed, more than half of the vessel was full of water, and even the plastic bags inside were breached 25. The concrete burial vault had been reported in 1977 as 'water-proofed,' but the city only learned in 2026 that this was not the case 29. The 1952 copper time capsule was found in a corroded and dented condition on its outside 35. Workers had located the copper box with X-rays and removed it by jackhammering the concrete cornerstone, approximately four weeks before the opening, without damaging the exterior marker 36.

Where things stand now (October 2026)

Format registries such as PRONOM and the Library of Congress's Sustainability of Digital Formats initiative advise which formats are likely to stay accessible and which need active management 66. Checksum verification lets institutions detect silent corruption, called bit rot, by periodically rechecking a fingerprint calculated for each file 68, and redundancy keeps multiple copies in different locations and on different media to reduce the risk of loss 69. In one example, Mountain View's 1976 bicentennial time capsule was found to have been damaged by water and mold, and its planned unveiling was scrapped 21. Its project director had said the capsule was very sturdy and that he had no expectation it would leak or fail 26.

Still unknown

Whether any future-letter service, patent, or public stunt has ever delivered a reply from the future is not settled, because those lanes have no verified entries in the checked evidence.

Whether postselected closed-timelike-curve models describe real physics or only hypothetical loops is still disputed, since the Deutsch and postselected models give different results.

Whether a 2026 result on information in loops could ever be turned into a signal that reaches a past moment is an open question with no settled answer in the evidence.

Whether the 1976 capsule water damage could have been prevented by a different sealing method is not established by the checked records.

Explore this colony and ask your own questions

Connected to other stories

United States also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, Did Israel's ten lost tribes really disappear forever?, How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Where did Cajun and Creole people really come from?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, How long has AI been around for everyone to use?, Is it really only three licks to reach a Tootsie Pop center?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Did South Gate, California's city government really have corruption problems?, Why hasn't anyone flown to Mars yet?, Did the Poythress Family Really Come From Pocahontas?, How much would 10 sales a day at $500 make?, Can you really make money trading crypto?, What was the first real crypto trade, and when did it happen?, Who Is the Richest Freemason, and Can We Prove It?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?, Can Anyone Really Name the First Horror Movie Ever Made?.

Bible also appears in How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, Did Israel's ten lost tribes really disappear forever?, What happened between Jacob and Esau in the Bible?.

Ronald Reagan also appears in How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Who Is the Richest Freemason, and Can We Prove It?.

Albert Einstein also appears in Why is the sky blue but sometimes gray?, Is it really only three licks to reach a Tootsie Pop center?, If Earth spins so fast, why don't spacecraft get left behind?.

France also appears in How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, Did the Knights Templar really invent banking?, Where did Cajun and Creole people really come from?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, Did the Poythress Family Really Come From Pocahontas?, What was the first real crypto trade, and when did it happen?, Who Is the Richest Freemason, and Can We Prove It?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?, Can Anyone Really Name the First Horror Movie Ever Made?.

YouTube also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Is it really only three licks to reach a Tootsie Pop center?, Can Anyone Really Name the First Horror Movie Ever Made?.

England also appears in How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Did the Knights Templar really invent banking?, Where did Cajun and Creole people really come from?, Did South Gate, California's city government really have corruption problems?, Did the Poythress Family Really Come From Pocahontas?, What was the first real crypto trade, and when did it happen?, Who Is the Richest Freemason, and Can We Prove It?, Can Anyone Really Name the First Horror Movie Ever Made?.

Central Intelligence Agency also appears in How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Why hasn't anyone flown to Mars yet?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?.

Sources

[1] supported · scholarly source
A reviewer describes the book as examining the problem of storing, reading and using digital documents for periods longer than 50 years.
"The book examines the problem of storing, reading and using digital documents for periods longer than 50 years."
Long-Term Preservation of Digital Documents (2006)
[2] supported · reference source
Open standards such as TIFF, PNG, XML, PDF/A and OpenDocument are considered relatively long-lived, so reformatting cycles are longer and it is much more likely that systems able to read the data will still exist in some years.
"Die Wahrscheinlichkeit, dass es in einigen Jahren noch Systeme und Programme gibt, die solche Daten lesen können, ist somit deutlich höher."
Translation: The probability that there will still be systems and programs in some years that can read such data is therefore significantly higher.
Langzeitarchivierung
[3] supported · reference source
The minimum conformance level, PDF/A-2b, is meant to guarantee that a document keeps its correct appearance for long-term archiving.
"garantiert das richtige Erscheinungsbild des Dokuments für eine Langzeitarchivierung."
Translation: guarantees the correct appearance of the document for long-term archiving.
PDF/A
[4] supported · scholarly source
Preserving and using data over the long term involves complicated research challenges and organizational efforts.
"While we are rapidly advancing from vulnerable physical solutions to superior, digital media, preserving and using data over the long term involves complicated research challenges and organization efforts."
Long-Term Preservation of Digital Documents (2006)
[5] supported · reference source
The high cost of maintaining digital holdings means only the most important data can be preserved in this way.
"Die hohen Kosten, die durch diese Pflege der Datenbestände entstehen, haben allerdings zur Folge, dass nur die wichtigsten Daten derart konserviert werden können."
Translation: The high costs arising from this maintenance of data holdings, however, mean that only the most important data can be preserved in this way.
Langzeitarchivierung
[6] supported · reference source
In the PDF/A-1b level, all images and fonts used must be contained within the PDF file itself, and references to resources not in the file are forbidden.
"Nicht erlaubt sind Referenzen auf Ressourcen, die nicht in der Datei enthalten sind. Alle verwendeten Bilder und Schriftarten (die Begrenzung auf die verwendeten Zeichen ist erlaubt) müssen in der PDF-Datei enthalten sein."
Translation: References to resources that are not contained in the file are not allowed. All images and fonts used (limiting to the characters used is permitted) must be contained in the PDF file.
PDF/A
[7] supported · reference source
Stephen Hawking formulated the chronology protection conjecture because some solutions of the equations of general relativity contain closed timelike curves, which would allow time travel backward along the time axis.
"Die Vermutung zum Schutz der Zeitordnung bzw. der Zeitfolge (engl. chronology protection conjecture bzw. CPC) wurde von Stephen Hawking formuliert, da in einigen Lösungen für die Gleichungen der Allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie geschlossene zeitartige Kurven (engl. closed timelike curves bzw. CTC) auftauchen und diese die Möglichkeit von Zeitreisen auf der Zeitachse rückwärts beinhalten."
Translation: The chronology protection conjecture (CPC) was formulated by Stephen Hawking, because some solutions of the equations of general relativity contain closed timelike curves (CTC), which contain the possibility of time travel backward along the time axis.
Liste ungelöster Probleme der Physik
[8] supported · reference source
In 2009, Heinrich Päs, Sandip Pakvasa, Thomas Weiler and James Dent showed that certain warped extra-dimensional spacetime scenarios could in principle allow closed timelike curves (time travel).
"2009 zeigten dieselben Autoren zusammen mit James Dent, dass solche Raumzeit -Szenarien im Prinzip geschlossene zeitartige Kurven ( Zeitreisen ) ermöglichen könnten."
Translation: In 2009 the same authors, together with James Dent, showed that such spacetime scenarios could in principle allow closed timelike curves (time travel).
Heinrich Päs
[9] supported · reference source
The proposal was covered in the media: New Scientist ran a 2006 article titled 'At last a way to test time travel', presenting the idea as a possible way to test time travel.
""At last a way to test time travel" , New Scientist 2552 p. 34, 20. Mai 2006 von Marcus Chown"
Translation: "At last a way to test time travel", New Scientist 2552 p. 34, 20 May 2006, by Marcus Chown
Heinrich Päs
[10] supported · scholarly source
Gödel's universe was dismissed as a model of physical reality because it is unlike the universe we live in.
"As a model of physical reality it can therefore be dismissed because it is unlike the universe we live in."
Closed timelike curves in general relativity
[11] supported · reference source
In 2005, Päs, Thomas Weiler and Sandip Pakvasa discussed the possibility that sterile neutrinos could take shortcuts through extra dimensions, the precursor idea to the later closed-timelike-curve work.
"2005 diskutierte er zusammen mit Thomas Weiler und Sandip Pakvasa die Möglichkeit, dass sterile Neutrinos Abkürzungen in Extra-Dimensionen nehmen könnten."
Translation: In 2005 he discussed, together with Thomas Weiler and Sandip Pakvasa, the possibility that sterile neutrinos could take shortcuts through extra dimensions.
Heinrich Päs
[12] supported · scholarly source
Van Stockum's spacetime with closed timelike curves describes a cylinder of rigidly rotating dust, but the cylinder is infinite in length, so it could not be realised in practice.
"Another simple space-time containingCTCs is that of van Stockum [2] which representsa cylinder of rigidly rotating dust; however, the cylinder is of infinite length so it could not be realised in practice."
Closed timelike curves in general relativity
[13] supported · scholarly source
Most spacetimes containing closed timelike curves were regarded as of merely theoretical interest because of some non-physical feature in their composition.
"Nearly all of these have been regarded as of merely theoretical interest because of some non-physi"
Closed timelike curves in general relativity
[14] supported · scholarly source
Bonnor argues that general relativity fails to give a satisfactory account of all phenomena within its terms of reference unless closed timelike curves receive a reasonable physical interpretation, and he calls for an urgent search for one.
"in default of a reasonable interpretation of CTC, general relativity does not give a satisfactory account of all phenomenawithin its terms of reference."
Closed timelike curves in general relativity
[15] supported · reference source
The oldest time capsule the document mentions was found in 1862 in the Johannisturm in Aschersleben: a sheet-metal box holding six documents, the oldest dated 1599.
"Bereits 1862 wurde im Johannisturm in Aschersleben eine Zeitkapsel in Form einer Blechbüchse mit sechs verschiedenen Urkunden gefunden, wovon die älteste auf 1599 datiert wurde und diverse Informationen zur Geschichte der Stadt enthalten waren."
Translation: Already in 1862, a time capsule in the form of a sheet-metal box containing six different documents was found in the Johannisturm in Aschersleben, of which the oldest was dated 1599 and contained various information about the history of the town.
Zeitkapsel
[16] supported · reference source
One of the Aschersleben documents, dated 12 July 1652, described the suffering caused by the Thirty Years' War in Aschersleben, and other writings reported the outbreak of the plague.
"Ein Schriftstück vom 12. Juli 1652 beschrieb beispielsweise die Leiden durch den Dreißigjährigen Krieg in Aschersleben, in anderen Schriften wird vom Auftreten der Pest berichtet."
Translation: A document dated 12 July 1652 described, for example, the suffering caused by the Thirty Years' War in Aschersleben; other writings report the appearance of the plague.
Zeitkapsel
[17] supported · reference source
The Crypt of Civilization at Oglethorpe University was sealed in 1940 in a disused swimming pool and is not to be opened until the year 8113.
"die im Jahr 1940 in einem aufgelassenen Schwimmbad an der Oglethorpe University verschlossen wurde und erst im Jahr 8113 geöffnet werden soll."
Translation: which was sealed in 1940 in a disused swimming pool at Oglethorpe University and is only to be opened in the year 8113.
Zeitkapsel
[18] supported · established source
The 1976 Lebanon Bicentennial time capsule was found to have suffered extensive water damage, with nearly every item affected by water, mold, and mildew.
"Capello said that nearly every item inside had been affected by water, mold, and mildew."
Lebanon city time capsule opened after 50 years: Here's what's inside - AOL
[19] supported · established source
Moisture seeping through the rusted steel container of the Public Square time capsule damaged a stack of documents about 10 inches high, which became stuck together and moldy and could not be salvaged.
"Moisture that seeped through the Public Square capsule's rusted steel container damaged a stack of documents about 10 inches high. Those papers were stuck together and moldy, so they were not salvageable, but at least 200 documents were saved."
1976 time capsule opened, 2026 time capsule to be buried in Hagerstown
[20] supported · niche source
The Kahoka time capsule, buried in 1976 and opened in July 2026, was found with much of its contents wet, stained, stuck together or destroyed.
"When the capsule was finally opened, much of what had been placed inside 50 years ago was wet, stained, stuck together or destroyed."
Water-Damaged Time Capsule Still Opens Window Into Kahoka’s Past
[21] supported · established source
Mountain View's 1976 bicentennial time capsule was found to have been damaged by water and mold, and the planned unveiling was scrapped.
"The plan has now been scrapped after the city discovered earlier this month that water and mold had damaged nearly all of the objects inside the capsule."
Mountain View cancels unveiling of bicentennial time capsule due to water damage - Mountain View Voice
[22] supported · established source
Mayor Sherry Capello said she found the water damage heartbreaking.
""It was heartbreaking," she said."
Lebanon city time capsule opened after 50 years: Here's what's inside - AOL
[23] supported · established source
Both Hagerstown Bicentennial capsules were dug up and opened before the public events so staff could check the condition of the capsules and their contents.
"Both had been dug up and opened before the events so staff could check the condition of the capsules and their contents."
1976 time capsule opened, 2026 time capsule to be buried in Hagerstown
[24] supported · niche source
Custodian Becki Krueger said she was really disappointed by the water damage found in the capsule's contents.
"“Boy, everything is sure water damaged,” Krueger said. “Really disappointed in this.”"
Water-Damaged Time Capsule Still Opens Window Into Kahoka’s Past
[25] documented · established source
When the lid was removed, more than half of the capsule's vessel was full of water, and even the plastic bags inside were breached.
"When the capsule lid was removed the next day, they saw that more than half of the vessel was filled with water, Kolb recounted. Even the plastic bags inside the capsule were breached, he said."
Mountain View cancels unveiling of bicentennial time capsule due to water damage - Mountain View Voice
[26] supported · established source
Alfred Daubert Jr., the bicentennial committee's project director, said the capsule was very sturdy and that he had no expectation it would leak or fail.
""That's a very sturdy time capsule, and we had no idea that it would leak or have any kind of a failure," he said."
Lebanon city time capsule opened after 50 years: Here's what's inside - AOL
[27] supported · established source
The capsule buried outside the Washington County Museum of Fine Arts was opened on a Tuesday, separately from the Public Square capsule.
"The other, buried outside the Washington County Museum of Fine Arts, was opened Tuesday ."
1976 time capsule opened, 2026 time capsule to be buried in Hagerstown
[28] supported · niche source
Krueger became emotional and said she was heartbroken as more damaged items came out of the capsule.
"“I am crying. I’m not sure what to say. I’m heartbroken.”"
Water-Damaged Time Capsule Still Opens Window Into Kahoka’s Past
[29] supported · established source
The concrete burial vault was reported in 1977 as 'water-proofed,' but the city only learned in 2026 that this was not the case.
"According to a news article at the time, the vault was “water-proofed.” However, that turned out not to be the case – a fact that the city only discovered earlier this month."
Mountain View cancels unveiling of bicentennial time capsule due to water damage - Mountain View Voice
[30] supported · established source
Historical Society archivist Shane Keenan said the artifacts were preserved better than most people expected despite the water damage.
"Historical Society archivist Shane Keenan said the artifacts were preserved better than most were expecting with the water damage."
Lebanon city time capsule opened after 50 years: Here's what's inside - AOL
[31] supported · established source
A Missouri city's 50-year-old time capsule was unearthed with water damage, and the city said in a social media post that the vault was being drained.
"The vault is currently being drained,” the city shared in a social media post."
Missouri city unearths 50-year-old time capsule, finds water damage
[32] supported · niche source
Before the final opening, Krueger noted that about a gallon of water had already leaked out of the capsule after it was recovered, and she was unsure whether the contents were damaged.
"“There was a little water that ran out, about a gallon or so, so I don’t know if there’s any damage in there or not,” she said."
Water-Damaged Time Capsule Still Opens Window Into Kahoka’s Past
[33] documented · established source
Assistant library director Bill Kolb said the team was disappointed that little of the contents could be recovered.
"“We were all really disappointed there wasn’t more material that was recoverable,” said Bill Kolb, Mountain View’s assistant library director."
Mountain View cancels unveiling of bicentennial time capsule due to water damage - Mountain View Voice
[34] supported · established source
Mayor Capello said the original capsule would be moved to City Hall instead of being reburied at the Liberty Pole, with a plaque marking the change because of the damage.
""We'll probably put a plaque out at the Liberty Pole at Coleman Memorial Park saying it's because of damage it's been moved to City Hall," she said."
Lebanon city time capsule opened after 50 years: Here's what's inside - AOL
[35] supported · established source
The 1952 copper time capsule was found in a corroded and dented condition on its outside.
"On the outside, it is a small, metal box, corroded and dented."
Time capsule opened on hospital’s 100th anniversary
[36] supported · established source
Workers located the copper box with X-rays and removed it by jackhammering the concrete cornerstone, approximately four weeks before the opening, without damaging the exterior marker.
"Workers used X-rays to locate the copper box inside the concrete cornerstone without damaging the exterior marker, then jackhammered it out approximately four weeks prior to the opening."
Time capsule opened on hospital’s 100th anniversary
[37] supported · established source
The copper box, placed at a 1952 hospital expansion cornerstone ceremony, contained blueprints, a Bible, historical pictures, photographs, and legal and historical documents.
"The copper box, originally placed during a hospital expansion cornerstone ceremony on September 10, 1952, contained, blueprints, a Bible, historical pictures, photographs and additional legal and historical documents from the era."
Time capsule opened on hospital’s 100th anniversary
[38] supported · reference source
The document does not discuss sealed messages or replies; it frames causal structure as describing which events can influence which others, and a closed timelike curve is the closed-loop case that would allow a signal to return to its own past.
"The causal relations between points in the manifold are interpreted as describing which events in spacetime can influence which other events."
Causal structure
[39] supported · scholarly source
Sending a qubit into the past through a postselected closed timelike curve (P-CTC) is analogous to teleporting the qubit's state, which is how the paper frames the backward-in-time mechanism.
"Sending a qubit into the past by a P-CTC is somewhat like teleporting the qubit’s state"
Perfect State Distinguishability and Computational Speedups with Postselected Closed Timelike Curves (2011)
[40] supported · reference source
A closed timelike curve is defined as a closed curve that is everywhere future-directed timelike (or everywhere past-directed timelike), which is the kind of loop a two-way causal exchange would require.
"A closed timelike curve is a closed curve which is everywhere future-directed timelike (or everywhere past-directed timelike)."
Causal structure
[41] supported · scholarly source
In general relativity, a closed timelike curve is a hypothetical construct: a worldline that loops back on itself so a particle can return to and interact with its own past.
"describes a worldline in spacetime looping back on itself, allowing a particle to return to and interact with its own past"
Experimental simulation of postselected closed timelike curves for decoding scrambled quantum information (2026)
[42] supported · scholarly source
Bennett and Schumacher's postselected quantum teleportation is the basis for a model of closed timelike curves that gives physically different results from Deutsch's model.
"Bennett and Schumacher’s postselected quantum teleportation is a model of closed timelike curves (CTCs) that leads to results physically different from Deutsch’s model."
Perfect State Distinguishability and Computational Speedups with Postselected Closed Timelike Curves (2011)
[43] supported · reference source
A closed null curve is the lightlike analogue, defined as a closed curve that is everywhere future-directed null (or everywhere past-directed null).
"A closed null curve is a closed curve which is everywhere future-directed null (or everywhere past-directed null)."
Causal structure
[44] supported · scholarly source
General relativity permits closed timelike curves, which is the starting point for treating a message sent backward in time as physically possible.
"existence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) [1–4]"
Retrocausal Capacity of a Quantum Channel: Communicating through Noisy Closed Timelike Curves (2026)
[45] supported · scholarly source
Under the postselected model, the future existence of a P-CTC can affect the present outcome of an experiment, unlike in Deutsch's model.
"in which the future existence of a P-CTC might affect the present outcome of an experiment."
Perfect State Distinguishability and Computational Speedups with Postselected Closed Timelike Curves (2011)
[46] supported · scholarly source
Combining forwards causality with retrocausality creates an ordering problem for dynamic production, because future events must produce past events while past events must also produce future events.
"because then the future events must produce the past events but also the past events must produce the future events"
Two Roads to Retrocausality
[47] supported · scholarly source
Unconditionally secure bit commitment is forbidden by quantum mechanics.
"Unconditionallysecurebitcommitmentisforbiddenbyquantummechanics."
Strong no-go theorem for Gaussian quantum bit commitment
[48] supported · scholarly source
The traditional picture of bit commitment is a one-way handover: Alice locks her bit in a safe, gives it to Bob, and later reveals it by handing over the key.
"Alice locks a secret bit into a safe that"
Strong no-go theorem for Gaussian quantum bit commitment
[49] supported · scholarly source
Under immutable timeline retrocausality, a present event's backwards influence cannot change anything in the present because that influence has already been exerted.
"‘immutable timeline retrocausality,’ where an event in the present having a retrocausal influence on the past can’t change anything about the present because its retrocausal influence has already been exerted"
Two Roads to Retrocausality
[50] supported · scholarly source
Price argued that the kind of retrocausality needed to explain Bell correlations cannot be used to create causal paradoxes such as a retrocausal grandfather paradox.
"Now as explored by Price in ref [15], it transpires that the kind of retrocausality needed to explain the Bell correlations actually can’t be used to create causal paradoxes of this kind"
Two Roads to Retrocausality
[51] supported · scholarly source
Closed time-like curves being possible inside our universe has long been a conjecture, and it was more recently revived by a series of papers.
"The possibility that the laws of physics might allow for the existence of closed time-like curves (CTCs) inside our universe has been a long time conjecture [1], which has been more recently revived by a series of papers [2–15]."
ERRATA: "TIME MACHINES: THE PRINCIPLE OF SELF-CONSISTENCY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF MINIMAL ACTION" (1996)
[52] supported · established source
Wormhole stability depends heavily on negative energy densities, which agrees with theoretical predictions but is limited by the lack of observed exotic matter.
"Wormhole simulations revealed that stability is highly dependent on negative energy densities, aligning with theoretical predictions but constrained by the absence of observable exotic matter."
THE PHYSICS OF TIME TRAVEL: POSSIBILITIES AND PARADOXES (2022)
[53] supported · niche source
Physicists say closed timelike curves, a loop in spacetime predicted by Einstein's relativity, could in principle let information return to an earlier point in time.
"One of the main ideas being studied is the “closed timelike curve,” a theoretical loop in spacetime predicted by Albert Einstein’s theory of relativity. According to scientists, such loops could potentially allow information to return to an earlier point in time without violating known physical laws."
Quantum Physics Research Revives Debate Over Possibility Of Sending Messages Back In Time
[54] supported · scholarly source
Wormhole geometries could in principle exist if matter violates the averaged weak energy conditions, and they can be exact solutions of Einstein's equations.
"Provided the matter density in some regions of our universe satisfies certain properties (i.e. it violates the so-called ‘averaged weak energy conditions,’ see, e.g., Refs. [3–6]), these 4-d Lorentzian wormhole geometries could, in principle, exist (at least they can be exact solutions of the Einstein equations)."
ERRATA: "TIME MACHINES: THE PRINCIPLE OF SELF-CONSISTENCY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF MINIMAL ACTION" (1996)
[55] supported · niche source
In some quantum experiments with entangled photons, the photons appeared to exchange information in ways that seemed retroactive, but no person or object actually travelled through time.
"In some studies, photons appeared to exchange information in ways that seemed retroactive, though researchers emphasised that no actual human or object travelled through time."
Quantum Physics Research Revives Debate Over Possibility Of Sending Messages Back In Time
[56] supported · scholarly source
The Novikov self-consistency principle says that only solutions that are globally self-consistent can occur in spacetimes with closed timelike curves, which is the physical constraint that makes such loops possible without contradiction.
"It states that the only solutions to the laws of physics that can occur in spacetimes containing closed timelike curves are those that are globally self-consistent"
Bootstrap Amplification: A Computational Analogue of the Bootstrap Paradox Governed by the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle (2026)
[57] supported · scholarly source
Generic relative motion of a wormhole's two mouths, or gravitational redshift at the mouths, can in principle produce closed time-like curves, so traversing the wormhole lets one travel into the past or future.
"if the wormhole is traversed from mouth to mouth, it acts as a ‘time machine’ allowing one to travel into the past or into the future."
ERRATA: "TIME MACHINES: THE PRINCIPLE OF SELF-CONSISTENCY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF MINIMAL ACTION" (1996)
[58] supported · scholarly source
Under the Novikov principle, no locally initiated event can create a contradiction, so the consistency constraint is what prevents paradoxes.
"and no locally initiated event can create a contradiction."
Bootstrap Amplification: A Computational Analogue of the Bootstrap Paradox Governed by the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle (2026)
[59] supported · scholarly source
The Principle of self-consistency, which restricts physically possible local events to those globally consistent around time loops, was explicitly formulated in the literature on these spacetimes.
"This requirement has been explicitly formulated as the ‘Principle of self-consistency,’ according to which the only solutions to the laws of physics that can occur locally in the real universe are those which are globally self-consistent [7, 9, 13–15]."
ERRATA: "TIME MACHINES: THE PRINCIPLE OF SELF-CONSISTENCY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF MINIMAL ACTION" (1996)
[60] supported · scholarly source
For a particle with fixed initial and final positions that traverses the wormhole once, the classical trajectories that minimize the action are exactly the globally self-consistent ones, so self-consistency follows from minimal action.
"the only possible trajectories (for a particle with fixed initial and final positions and which traverses the wormhole once) minimizing the classical action are those which are globally self-consistent, and that the ‘Principle of self-consistency’ (originally introduced by Novikov) is thus a natural consequence of the ‘Principle of minimal action.’"
ERRATA: "TIME MACHINES: THE PRINCIPLE OF SELF-CONSISTENCY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF MINIMAL ACTION" (1996)
[61] supported · scholarly source
In the bootstrap paradox, a traveller acquires a document at a later time, carries it back to an earlier time, and delivers it so that the traveller can read it later, creating a loop.
"The canonical example: a traveller acquires a document at time t₂, travels to t₁ < t₂, and delivers that document to an agent who publishes it, so that the traveller can read it at t₂."
Bootstrap Amplification: A Computational Analogue of the Bootstrap Paradox Governed by the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle (2026)
[62] supported · scholarly source
Novikov and colleagues observed that self-consistent solutions to such loops arise naturally from imposing fixed-point boundary conditions.
"Crucially, Novikov and colleagues observe that self-consistent solutions to such loops arise naturally from the imposition of fixed-point boundary conditions [1]."
Bootstrap Amplification: A Computational Analogue of the Bootstrap Paradox Governed by the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle (2026)
[63] supported · scholarly source
The report's central proposal is the emulation strategy: emulating obsolete systems on future, unknown systems so that a digital document's original software can still run despite being obsolete.
"The central idea of the emulation strategy is to emulate obsolete systems on future, unknown systems, so that a digital document's original software can be run in the future despite being obsolete."
Avoiding Technological Quicksand: Finding a Viable Technical Foundation for Digital Preservation (1999)
[64] supported · scholarly source
The report states that no viable long-term strategy yet exists to ensure digital information will remain readable in the future.
"There is as yet no viable long-term strategy to ensure that digital information will be readable in the future."
Avoiding Technological Quicksand: Finding a Viable Technical Foundation for Digital Preservation (1999)
[65] supported · niche source
Preserving a digital object under the view path model requires extending the metadata of the primary object and storing secondary objects, so that the object's original environment, such as applications or operating systems, can be reproduced.
"The view path model requires extensions of the metadata sets of the primary object as well as additionally stored secondary objects resulting in a reproduction of the object's environment, e.g. applications or operating systems."
Requirements for Emulation as a Long-term Preservation Strategy (2009)
[66] supported · niche source
Format registries such as PRONOM and the Library of Congress's Sustainability of Digital Formats initiative advise which formats are likely to stay accessible and which need active management.
"Format registries such as PRONOM and the Library of Congress's Sustainability of Digital Formats initiative provide guidance on which formats are most likely to remain accessible and which require active management."
CHALLENGES AND STRATEGIES IN LONG-TERM DIGITAL LIBRARY ARCHIVING (2026)
[67] supported · niche source
Emulation is proposed as a complement to migration, the otherwise dominant digital preservation strategy, and is said to have convincing advantages especially for dynamic digital objects.
"It can act as a complement to the otherwise dominant digital preservation strategies of migration and has convincing advantages, especially for dynamic digital objects."
Requirements for Emulation as a Long-term Preservation Strategy (2009)
[68] supported · niche source
Checksum verification lets institutions detect silent corruption, called bit rot, by periodically rechecking a fingerprint calculated for each file.
"Checksum verification, in which a mathematical fingerprint is calculated for each file and periodically rechecked, allows institutions to detect silent corruption, known as bit rot, before it spreads."
CHALLENGES AND STRATEGIES IN LONG-TERM DIGITAL LIBRARY ARCHIVING (2026)
[69] supported · niche source
Redundancy and geographic distribution keep multiple copies of digital objects in different locations and on different media to reduce the risk of loss.
"redundancy and geographic distribution, which ensure that multiple copies of digital objects exist in different locations and on different media, reducing the risk of loss from disaster or media failure."
CHALLENGES AND STRATEGIES IN LONG-TERM DIGITAL LIBRARY ARCHIVING (2026)
[70] supported · niche source
Physicist Gerald Feinberg gave faster-than-light particles a formal place in theory in the 1960s, using 'imaginary mass.'
"The idea goes back at least to the 1960s, when physicist Gerald Feinberg tried to give faster-than-light particles a formal place in theory."
New tachyon theory could unlock the secrets of time travel and causality - The Brighter Side of News
[71] supported · niche source
If a tachyon could outrun light, different observers could disagree about the order of events, so one frame could see a particle absorbed before it was emitted.
"If a tachyon could outrun light, then under some circumstances different observers could disagree about the order of events. A particle emitted in one frame of reference could look, in another, like it was absorbed before it was ever sent."
New tachyon theory could unlock the secrets of time travel and causality - The Brighter Side of News
[72] supported · niche source
The reversal of event order from faster-than-light particles revived the old fear that tachyons would destroy causality.
"That kind of reversal fed the old fear that tachyons would demolish causality itself."
New tachyon theory could unlock the secrets of time travel and causality - The Brighter Side of News
[73] supported · primary source
The document says that the causal self-consistency condition for closed timelike curves can produce nonlinear interactions on qubits that respect chronology, which is the kind of backward-in-time physics that a backward message would raise. It does not discuss sealed boxes opened on a future date.
"The causal self-consistency condition for closed timelike curves can give rise to nonlinear interactions on chronology-respecting qubits."
Closed time like curves enable perfect state distinguishability (2008)
[74] documented · primary source
Gott spacetime contains closed timelike curves but has no locally anomalous stress-energy, so the paper treats it as a case where CTCs exist without that particular anomaly.
"Gott spacetime has closed timelike curves, but no locally anomalous stress-energy."
Quantum field theory in spaces with closed time-like curves (1992)
[75] supported · scholarly source
Information encoded in a quantum field can remain accessible to a receiver who switches on their detector at a later time, after the light-speed signal has already passed.
"by switching on his detector at latter times he will still be able to access information that is kept encoded in the field."
Timelike information broadcasting in cosmology (2016)
[76] supported · primary source
The document claims that a party with access to closed timelike curves could transmit an arbitrarily large amount of classical information using a quantum system of fixed size.
"In principle, he can transmit an arbitrarily large amount of classical information with a quantum system of fixed size."
Closed time like curves enable perfect state distinguishability (2008)
[77] supported · primary source
The interacting quantum field theory built on this spacetime is not unitary, because field operators can create real, on-shell particles in the acausal region (the region containing closed timelike curves).
"The resultant interacting quantum field theory is not unitary because the field operators can create real, on-shell, particles in the acausal region."
Quantum field theory in spaces with closed time-like curves (1992)
[78] supported · primary source
Within the acausal region the effective potential becomes complex and probability is not conserved.
"As a result, the effective potential within the acausal region is complex, and probability is not conserved."
Quantum field theory in spaces with closed time-like curves (1992)
[79] supported · scholarly source
Closed timelike curves are paths through spacetime that effectively travel backwards in time, so a traveler on one can in principle interact with their own past self.
"Closed timelike curves (CTCs) are trajectories in spacetime that effectively travel backwards in time: a test particle following a CTC can in principle interact with its former self in the past."
Closed timelike curves via post-selection: theory and experimental demonstration
[80] supported · scholarly source
Closed timelike curves appear in many solutions of Einstein's field equations.
"CTCs appear in many solutions of Einstein’s field equations and any future quantum version of general relativity will have to reconcile them with the requirements of quantum mechanics and of quantumfieldtheory."
Closed timelike curves via post-selection: theory and experimental demonstration