The First 'Real' Crypto Trade Depends on What You Mean by Real
The first recorded dollar price for bitcoin came from a website that priced it using electricity costs, and the first recorded sale for dollars happened in October 2009 5474. The first matched trade on a bitcoin exchange came nine months later, and what counts as 'real' depends on which of these you choose 5874.

In short
The earliest documented candidate is a sale on October 12, 2009, when Martti Malmi sold 5,050 BTC for $5.02 74. The first matched trade on the Mt. Gox exchange happened on July 17, 2010, when 20 bitcoin changed hands for just under a dollar 5870. Before bitcoin, e-gold and Liberty Reserve offered digital units of value tied to outside measures. E-gold units were denominated by weight of gold, with each unit a claim on a set amount of physical gold, while Liberty Reserve units were tied to the U.S. dollar, the euro, or ounces of gold, and deposited money was converted into them 3378. Today's answer is shaped by law: Japan requires exchange registration 13, the SEC issued a March 17, 2026 interpretation of how federal securities laws apply to certain crypto assets 38, and Brazil requires firms that let customers trade, hold, or send crypto to hold a license, with an October 30 compliance deadline 25.
A 1920 detour: when does a new asset count as income?
Before crypto, American courts had to decide when a receipt of value counts as income. In March 1920 the Supreme Court held that stock dividends may not be taxed as income, striking down parts of the 1916 income tax act that taxed them 6. The Court reasoned that a stock dividend takes nothing from the corporation's property and adds nothing to the shareholder's property 8.
The Court did add a twist: if a shareholder later sells dividend shares at a profit, that profit is taxable income, even though the shareholder had not been taxed on receiving the shares 10. The closest historical analogy in the checked evidence is the March 1920 ruling that stock dividends are not taxable as income 7. That ruling concerns receiving a new asset distributed on an existing holding, but the source says it does not address cryptocurrency or whether such receipts count as trades 7.
Digital gold and online currencies before bitcoin
E-gold denominated its units by the weight of gold rather than in currency units, so each unit was a claim on a set amount of physical gold 33. The issuer did not itself exchange e-gold for other currencies; trading against dollars happened through private exchange offices, and in Russia companies such as RUpay and ExchEngine converted e-gold to and from rubles 3435. The official rate of one XAU of e-gold in dollars rose from about $422.20 at the start of 2005 to about $633.50 by spring 2006 36.
The 2009 dollar price and the first recorded sale
The first recorded dollar price for bitcoin was calculated in October 2009 by the website New Liberty Standard, at $0.000764 per BTC, based on electricity costs 54. Its owner, Martti Malmi, used the cost of electricity to mine BTC as the basis for the price 56. The rate was posted on the site's Exchange Rate page, cited through an archived copy 57.
The first sale that gave bitcoin a dollar value was made on October 12, 2009, when Martti Malmi sold 5050 bitcoins for $5.02 74. Another source describes the same October 2009 sale, in which Finnish software developer Martti Malmi traded 5,050 BTC for US$5.02, but it does not say whether Malmi or his counterparty set that price 73.
Mt. Gox opens its doors to strangers
Mt. Gox began in 2006 as a platform for trading Magic: The Gathering Online cards, not bitcoin, and its founder, Jed McCaleb, had planned that card market before he learned about Bitcoin 6061. After learning about bitcoin, McCaleb reused the mtgox.com domain for a bitcoin exchange 64. Its first matched trade happened on July 17, 2010, when two parties traded 20 bitcoin for just under a dollar, with bitcoin priced around $0.04951 5870.
The site itself went online on July 18, 2010 59. Sources put the first trade one day before the site opened, which is one reason to read the dates carefully 5859. Each account had a fiat sub-account and a bitcoin sub-account, and sale proceeds went back into the same fiat account 62. On October 10, 2010, Mt. Gox switched its main funding option from PayPal to Liberty Reserve because of chargeback fraud 67.
In 2011 McCaleb sold Mt. Gox to French developer Mark Karpelès, who was living in Japan 68. The exchange was later hacked, and billions of dollars worth of BTC was stolen 72.
Rules take shape: Japan and Brazil
Japan's 2016 amendment to the Payment Services Act was passed on 25 May 2016 and took effect on 1 April 2017 15. From that date, the amendment wrote 'virtual currency' such as Bitcoin into Japanese law 22. Crypto-asset exchange business in Japan requires registration with the Prime Minister under that Act 13. The Act defines a crypto-asset as property of value that can be used to pay for goods and bought and sold with unspecified parties, and that can be transferred electronically 16. Crypto-asset exchanges are also designated business operators under the Act on Prevention of Transfer of Criminal Proceeds, so anti-money-laundering obligations apply to them 21.
Japan renamed 'virtual currency' to 'crypto-asset' through an amendment that took effect in 2020, with the changes taking effect on 1 May 2020 1418. In Brazil, the Legal Framework for Virtual Assets passed in 2022 gave the Central Bank authority over the crypto sector 23.
Where things stand now
In the United States, the SEC issued an interpretation on March 17, 2026, clarifying how federal securities laws apply to certain crypto assets 38. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins said most crypto assets are not themselves securities 43. The SEC regulates crypto assets that function as investment contracts, while the CFTC regulates digital commodities and the derivatives built on them 39. The SEC's September 2026 'Regulation Crypto Assets' framework is only a proposal, not an adopted rule 12. In the EU, the MiCA grandfathering transition expired on July 1, 2026, and unlicensed providers must cease EU operations after that date 47. MiCA covers all 27 EU member states under a single passport license 49.
Tax reporting is also tightening: the CARF, adopted in the EU as DAC8, requires providers to collect user tax information and report it to tax authorities 3. That is a reporting duty, not a rule about showing prices or fees to buyers 34. Banks are moving in too: Deutsche Bank pledged regulated crypto custody for European institutional and corporate clients by the end of 2026, subject to pending approvals, and individual account holders cannot use that service 3032. In Brazil, March 2026 filings showed zero virtual asset holdings on banks' books, even though banks can custody crypto for clients 31.
On the trading side, the price you see is not always the price you get. Slippage is the gap between the price at which a trade was submitted and the price at which it was actually executed 51, and thin liquidity lets a few big orders move prices 50. Perpetual futures carry a funding rate that changes over time and is typically charged every eight hours, so the true cost of holding a position is not fixed when the trade is placed 53. In the bitcoin case, a governing-law ruling could limit roughly 16,000 Chinese victims to recovering their principal and interest rather than a share of the bitcoins' gains, which are now about 200 times the original purchase price 2. The court has not yet decided whether the investors hold property rights in the bitcoins under Chinese law, so the property question remains open 1.
Still unknown
Which definition of 'real' should win: the October 2009 peer sale for $5.02, or the first matched trade on an exchange in July 2010? The evidence supports both, and the 2009 sale's price-setting is not settled [73][58].
The evidence does not say whether early Liberty Reserve or e-gold users got their balances back after those services closed, so the question of what happened to trades already made is still open [75].
The evidence contains nothing about the 2010 pizza purchase, early altcoin or token launch trades, or how consumers can complain and recover losses, so those lanes are thin. It also does not show whether 2026 rules require a platform to show the full price and fees before a buyer confirms.
Explore this colony and ask your own questionsConnected to other stories
United States also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, Did Israel's ten lost tribes really disappear forever?, How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Where did Cajun and Creole people really come from?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, How long has AI been around for everyone to use?, Is it really only three licks to reach a Tootsie Pop center?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Has Anyone Ever Used the Internet for Time Travel?, Did South Gate, California's city government really have corruption problems?, Why hasn't anyone flown to Mars yet?, Did the Poythress Family Really Come From Pocahontas?, How much would 10 sales a day at $500 make?, Can you really make money trading crypto?, Who Is the Richest Freemason, and Can We Prove It?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?, Can Anyone Really Name the First Horror Movie Ever Made?.
European Union also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, How long has AI been around for everyone to use?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Can you really make money trading crypto?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?.
Internal Revenue Service also appears in How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, What are the best ways to make money online in 2027?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Did South Gate, California's city government really have corruption problems?, How much would 10 sales a day at $500 make?, Can you really make money trading crypto?.
United States Congress also appears in How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Why hasn't anyone flown to Mars yet?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?.
Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Can you really make money trading crypto?.
Supreme Court of the United States also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, How early did people really reach Australia and Asia?, Is the US government really poisoning us with processed food?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Did South Gate, California's city government really have corruption problems?.
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission also appears in Do crypto insiders really take money from other investors?, How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, How long has AI been around for everyone to use?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Can you really make money trading crypto?.
United States Department of the Treasury also appears in How did the Federal Reserve Act change who could create money?, Could One Bitcoin Really Be Worth $200,000?, Have leaked Project 2025 plans really been happening?, Can you really make money trading crypto?, Is the US really just taking minerals from Congo?.
Sources
"The court has not yet decided whether the investors hold property rights in the bitcoins under Chinese law."U.K. Court Rules Chinese Law Governs Recovery of Over 61,000 Seized Bitcoins - Caixin Global · saved copy
"The decision could limit the roughly 16,000 Chinese victims who have joined the U.K. recovery proceedings to recovering their principal and interest, rather than a share of the bitcoins’ gains."U.K. Court Rules Chinese Law Governs Recovery of Over 61,000 Seized Bitcoins - Caixin Global · saved copy
"The rules will require Crypto-Asset Service Providers (CASPs) to collect information on users including individuals' tax residences and tax identification numbers and report that information to their domestic tax authority."Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework
"Full transaction details on the acquisition and disposal of cryptocurrencies and other digital assets, whether for fiat money or other digital assets."Directive on Administrative Co-operation in the field of Taxation (2011/16)
"It is only after those earnings are paid to the stockholders that they become taxable. Now they only become taxable if paid in cash."Image 3 of New-York tribune (New York [N.Y.]), March 9, 1920
"Stock divi dividends - dends dividends may not be taxed as income"Image 2 of Great Falls daily tribune (Great Falls, Mont.), March 9, 1920
"These two rulings of the court were the verdict declaring that stock divi divik - k divik 5 arc not taxable as income"Image 29 of Evening star (Washington, D.C.), March 14, 1920
"We are clear that not only does a stock dividend really take nothing from the property of the corporatoin and adds nothing to that of the shareholder"Image 2 of Great Falls daily tribune (Great Falls, Mont.), March 9, 1920
"The taxation of stock dividends had not a leg to stand upon"Image 29 of Evening star (Washington, D.C.), March 14, 1920
"such profit, like any other, is income and, so far as it may have arisen since the sixteenth amendment, is taxable by congress without ap apportionment"Image 2 of Great Falls daily tribune (Great Falls, Mont.), March 9, 1920
"Central Bank Resolutions 519, 520 and 521 took effect on 2 February 2026, requiring virtual asset service providers to obtain authorisation and meet strict governance rules."Brazil Tightens School Phone Rules and Crypto Oversight (riotimesonline.com, 2026-08)
"The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed a new framework, “Regulation Crypto Assets,” specifically designed to enable cryptocurrency projects to raise capital."U . S . Securities and Exchange Commission Proposes Allowing Crypto Projects to Raise Up to $75 Mln Under Special Rules (fixygen.ua, 2026-09)
"暗号資産交換業について内閣総理大臣の登録制を導入し(第63条の2)"資金決済に関する法律
"日本では2020年施行の改正 資金決済法 により暗号資産へと変更された"
"改正法 [ 4 ] は、2016年(平成28年)5月25日に成立し、2017年(平成29年)4月1日に施行した。"資金決済に関する法律
"不特定の者を相手方として購入及び売却を行うことができる財産的価値"
"At the same time, issuers must disclose information to investors and will continue to be subject to laws regarding fraud and market manipulation."U . S . Securities and Exchange Commission Proposes Allowing Crypto Projects to Raise Up to $75 Mln Under Special Rules (fixygen.ua, 2026-09)
"この改正資金決済法・改正金融商品取引法は、2020年5月1日に施行された"
"Existing virtual asset service providers must apply for authorisation between 2 February and 29 October 2026. From 30 October 2026, licensed banks and payment firms can no longer deal with unauthorised VASPs, effectively cutting them off from the financial system."Brazil Tightens School Phone Rules and Crypto Oversight (riotimesonline.com, 2026-08)
"The SEC is also proposing a safe harbor mechanism that, subject to meeting a number of requirements, allows the crypto asset itself to be separated from the initial investment contract."U . S . Securities and Exchange Commission Proposes Allowing Crypto Projects to Raise Up to $75 Mln Under Special Rules (fixygen.ua, 2026-09)
"暗号資産交換業も犯罪収益移転防止法における特定事業者となる(犯罪収益移転防止法2条2項32号)。"資金決済に関する法律
"ビットコインなどの「仮想通貨」が日本の法律に定められた"
"Brazil passed its Legal Framework for Virtual Assets in 2022, handing the Central Bank authority over the sector, and three resolutions the bank published in November 2025 gave that authority teeth."Brazilian Banks Expand Crypto Offerings as Regulation Takes Hold (finance.yahoo.com, 2026-09)
"According to State Street's March regulatory update, regulators have confirmed that banks may provide and outsource crypto custody and execution services."Deutsche Bank Is Weeks From Holding Bitcoin and Ethereum for Clients . Could Other Big Banks Follow ? (aol.com, 2026-10)
"Any firm that lets customers trade, hold, or send crypto now needs a license, a minimum capital cushion, and segregated client accounts, with an October 30 deadline to comply."Brazilian Banks Expand Crypto Offerings as Regulation Takes Hold (finance.yahoo.com, 2026-09)
"The Basel Committee, which develops global bank capital rules, discussed reviewing its crypto regulations in February, suggesting that easing these standards could make it more financially viable for banks to enter the crypto market."Deutsche Bank Is Weeks From Holding Bitcoin and Ethereum for Clients . Could Other Big Banks Follow ? (aol.com, 2026-10)
"One of those rules, Resolution 521, treats any purchase or exchange of a dollar-pegged token as a foreign exchange operation , the same reporting bar applied to sending money abroad."Brazilian Banks Expand Crypto Offerings as Regulation Takes Hold (finance.yahoo.com, 2026-09)
"BNY ( NYSE:BK ) has pioneered crypto custody, starting services for Bitcoin and Ether in October 2022 after receiving approval from New York's financial regulator."Deutsche Bank Is Weeks From Holding Bitcoin and Ethereum for Clients . Could Other Big Banks Follow ? (aol.com, 2026-10)
"Proprietary exposure only exists, he said, when a bank buys crypto with its own money and absorbs the price, liquidity, and credit risk that comes with it. By that standard, none of Brazil's banks have crossed into ownership yet."Brazilian Banks Expand Crypto Offerings as Regulation Takes Hold (finance.yahoo.com, 2026-09)
"Deutsche Bank first announced its custody service on September 16, pledging that European institutional and corporate clients would have access to regulated custody by the end of 2026, pending regulatory approvals."Deutsche Bank Is Weeks From Holding Bitcoin and Ethereum for Clients . Could Other Big Banks Follow ? (aol.com, 2026-10)
"Central Bank filings dated March 2026 and reviewed by Folha show zero holdings of virtual assets on the books of Brazilian banks, even though institutions can custody and process crypto on clients' behalf."Brazilian Banks Expand Crypto Offerings as Regulation Takes Hold (finance.yahoo.com, 2026-09)
"This service targets institutions and corporations, so individual account holders will not be able to use it to store cryptocurrencies."Deutsche Bank Is Weeks From Holding Bitcoin and Ethereum for Clients . Could Other Big Banks Follow ? (aol.com, 2026-10)
"E-gold исчислялся по весу золота, денежных единиц E-gold не существовало."
"Эмитент E-gold не проводил операций по обмену e-gold на другие валюты. Операции по обмену e-gold как на фиатные валюты, так и на электронные ( Webmoney и пр.) осуществлялись через частные обменные пункты."
"В России, например, обменом e-gold ↔ RUB занимались компании RUpay , ExchEngine и другие [ 1 ] ."
"На начало 2005 года официальный курс 1 XAU e-gold составлял 422,20 $, к весне 2006 года 1 XAU вырос до 633,50 $."
"The Securities and Exchange Commission (“Commission” or “SEC”) issues herein an interpretation regarding the application of the Federal securities laws to certain types of crypto assets and certain transactions involving crypto assets."Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto ...
"The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) today issued an interpretation clarifying how the federal securities laws apply to certain crypto assets and transactions involving crypto assets."SEC Clarifies the Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
"The Securities and Exchange Commission regulates crypto assets that function as investment contracts, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission regulates digital commodities and the derivatives markets built on them."SEC vs CFTC Crypto Rules: Who Regulates What in 2026
"The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) provides herein guidance relating to that interpretation."Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto ...
"The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) joined the interpretation to provide guidance that the CFTC and its staff will administer the Commodity Exchange Act consistent with the Commission’s interpretation."SEC Clarifies the Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
"Last Reviewed or Updated: March 23, 2026"Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto ...
"It also acknowledges what the former administration refused to recognize – that most crypto assets are not themselves securities."SEC Clarifies the Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
"Designated contract markets (DCMs) handle exchange-traded derivatives on these assets, requiring CFTC registration and ongoing compliance."SEC vs CFTC Crypto Rules: Who Regulates What in 2026
"Provides a coherent token taxonomy for digital commodities, digital collectibles, digital tools, stablecoins, and digital securities."SEC Clarifies the Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
"a token offered initially as part of an investment contract can later cease to be subject to that contract, once the issuer’s promises are fulfilled and the network no longer depends on centralized efforts"SEC vs CFTC Crypto Rules: Who Regulates What in 2026
"The European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) is entering its most consequential phase, with the grandfathering transition period set to expire on July 1, 2026. Any crypto-asset service provider operating in the EU without a MiCA-compliant license will be forced to cease operations after this critical date"SEC-CFTC Token Classification 2026 | Spoted Crypto
"Clarifies the application of federal securities laws to airdrops, protocol mining, protocol staking, and the wrapping of a non-security crypto asset."SEC Clarifies the Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets
"MiCA represents the world's first comprehensive, multi-national crypto regulatory framework, covering all 27 EU member states under a single passport license"SEC-CFTC Token Classification 2026 | Spoted Crypto
"Liquidity refers to the market's ability to absorb large buy and sell orders at stable prices. Per Krenn, standard dated futures are largely illiquid, meaning a few big orders can easily sway prices in either direction, raising slippage and spoiling execution for traders."The good and the bad of perps , according to crypto traders (coindesk.com, 2026-07)
"Slippage is the price at which the trade was submitted and the price at which it was actually executed."The good and the bad of perps , according to crypto traders (coindesk.com, 2026-07)
"perps offer better fills, meaning your order is executed at a more favorable price than you expected or than the ongoing market quote when you sent the order, lower fees"The good and the bad of perps , according to crypto traders (coindesk.com, 2026-07)
"A perpetual futures contract, on the other hand, has a funding rate that changes over time and is typically charged every eight hours."The good and the bad of perps , according to crypto traders (coindesk.com, 2026-07)
"The first recorded BTC price came in October 2009 when New Liberty Standard calculated a value of $0.000764 per BTC based on electricity costs."How Much Was Bitcoin When It First Came Out? Price History Explained
"The first attempt to assign Bitcoin a dollar value came from a site called New Liberty Standard in October 2009."How Much Was Bitcoin When It First Came Out? Price History Explained
"The owner, a user known as Martti Malmi, used the cost of electricity to mine BTC as the basis for a price."How Much Was Bitcoin When It First Came Out? Price History Explained
"https://web.archive.org/web/20091229132610/http://newlibertystandard.wetpaint.com/page/Exchange+Rate"Bitcoin Price History Chart + Historical Events 2009-2026
"On July 17, 2010, two trading parties matched for the first time on the Mt. Gox Bitcoin exchange when 20 bitcoin changed hands for just under a dollar."Ten Years of Bitcoin Market Data
"The exchange went online on July 18, 2010."Mt. Gox - Bitcoin Wiki
"In 2006, a programmer, Jed McCaleb, created Mt. Gox as a platform for trading "Magic: The Gathering Online" cards."The Story of Mt. Gox: Explained
"McCaleb registered the domain mtgox.com for a proposed market in cards used by the game Magic: The Gathering Online"View source for Mt. Gox - BitcoinWiki
"A registrant on Mt. Gox had at least two sub-accounts: one for bitcoins (BTC), and one for fiat currency. Bitcoins were bought using funds from the trader's fiat account, and the proceeds from the sale of bitcoins were deposited into the same account."Mt. Gox - Bitcoin Wiki
"The Mt. Gox site was repurposed in 2010 to launch a Bitcoin exchange, capitalizing on the growing interest in cryptocurrency."The Story of Mt. Gox: Explained
"After learning about Bitcoin, McCaleb reused the domain for an exchange that opened on 18 July 2010."View source for Mt. Gox - BitcoinWiki
"On its first day of operation, Mt. Gox enabled the trading of just 20 Bitcoins, each selling for a mere 5 cents."The Story of Mt. Gox: Explained
"Programmer Jed McCaleb launched it as a Bitcoin market in July 2010 and transferred control to Mark Karpelès in 2011."View source for Mt. Gox - BitcoinWiki
"On October 10, 2010 the exchange switched from PayPal to Liberty Reserve as the main funding option as a result of chargeback fraud."Mt. Gox - Bitcoin Wiki
"In 2011, McCaleb sold Mt. Gox to French developer, Mark Karpelès, who was living in Japan at the time."The Story of Mt. Gox: Explained
"Exactly ten years back on July 17, 2010, the exchange executed its first Bitcoin trade with a 20 BTC order between two parties."10 Years Ago: First Bitcoin Trade on MT.Gox For $0.05 Per BTC
"The total value of the transaction was just $0.99. Bitcoin’s price was trading at $0.04951 back then."10 Years Ago: First Bitcoin Trade on MT.Gox For $0.05 Per BTC
"Back in the years, Mt. Gox was the predominant Bitcoin exchange, and as such, it controlled a huge percentage of the market."10 Years Ago: First Bitcoin Trade on MT.Gox For $0.05 Per BTC
"Soon after, it was hacked, and billions of USD worth of BTC was stolen – the case goes on until today."10 Years Ago: First Bitcoin Trade on MT.Gox For $0.05 Per BTC
"Things would change in October of that year, however, when Finnish software developer Martti Malmi traded 5,050 BTC for US$5.02."A Short History of the Bitcoin Price - Crypto.com International
"The first time Bitcoin actually gained value was on October 12, 2009, when Martti Malmi, a Finnish developer that helped Satoshi work on Bitcoin, sold 5050 Bitcoins for $5.02."Bitcoin Price History Chart + Historical Events 2009-2026
"Liberty Reserve was a Costa Rica -based centralized digital currency service that billed itself as the "oldest, safest and most popular payment processor , serving millions all around a world"."Liberty Reserve
"The Hawarden City Council started with an * Issue of 300 trade coupons, worth $1 each, to pay workers on a paving project."Image 24 of Evening star (Washington, D.C.), December 9, 1932
"From 2002 to 2006, United States businessmen Arthur Budovsky and Vladimir Kats ran a digital currency exchange service known as Gold Age ."Liberty Reserve
"Deposited funds were then "converted" into Liberty Reserve Dollars or Liberty Reserve Euros, which were tied to the value of the U.S. dollar and the euro , respectively, or to ounces of gold."Liberty Reserve
"The service made money by charging a small fee, about 1%, on each transfer. [ 1 ] Transactions were "100% irrevocable"."Liberty Reserve
"Service was popular among currency brokers and multilevel marketing companies. [ 5 ] According to Forex Magnates, a specialized forex news service, Liberty Reserve was "the leading payment channel for traders in emerging and frontier markets.""Liberty Reserve
Ask your own question